Samwise137 said:
I guess a little of both. Another teacher I know from a nearby district suggested that if Valve really wanted to push this for education they could release a version specifically FOR education without the plot and occasional blood splatters (blood being the biggest hindrance for administrators; we have to keep things 'school appropriate'). Don't get me wrong, I'm all for games as educational tools but it's just VERY difficult to get administrators to go along with it.
I'd say they shouldn't remove the plot. Games are great for learning, but they should be doing it slightly subtly: the game's plot can be encouraging to kids, to keep them playing while they're learning. I mean, just because it's educational doesn't mean it can't be fun, right?
OT: I've already recommended this to several friends.
They're all getting Portal 2 now.