Uh, what?Staskala said:But for that to work you would need to portray the "bad guys" as sympathetic, acting out of actually good ideals, portraying their rule as not being all that bad and so on.unabomberman said:What is it that people expect when they turn americans into afghan insurgents? To me it is glaringly obvious. Sadly, I believe this game plays out to the exceptionalism present in a large part of the developed world's youth, and most people wonn't even bother to make the connection.
From within the context, this game is trying to appeal to the whole "Oh, shit! They're in my backyard, gotta fight them off!" mentality. Of course, most people won't even bother to make the connection (hey, the game's called HOMEFRONT) but it's there.
After all, not even America attacks countries just for the fun of it, there is an underlying factor of ideals, various intentions (even goodwill), morals and whatnot.
Then you get to questions like if resistance really is always justifed or if it's just action out of principle (especially if the resistance is just a small minority with most people being happy with the new regime) and so on.
Yes, that's very interesting stuff, but if your enemies are 100% evil, then I'm sorry, but there's nothing of that here.
Of course the game could be interesting; if it actually started with America invading North Korea and then losing and getting occupied all the while portraying North Korea as being on the same moral ground (or even above), I'd consider this a must-buy for me.
Not that it would make any more sense, but it would be far more interesting than the generic premise it seems to have.
But, yes. Putting North Korea and the U.S at exactly the same moral ground is what I'm doing. To the layman there would be no difference: Zilch. No country wants to get invaded, no matter the set of ideals the invading force happens to be waving, just ask the Iraqis--the U.S kicks Saddam's butt, and what happens? Yes, the question was rethorical.
I doubt any Afghan insurgent sees the U.S troops as anything other than "100% evil." That's what I mean.