The Rockerfly said:
I would happily say Bioshock but I loved Bioshock and I know many didn't
Fallout 3 would also be another choice but again, others didn't like it
If you wanted something that everyone can agree on:
Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
Seriously, who would disagree
I would, I just don't like the way the aiming feels so light (I prefer the way it was in CoD2).
O.T. I'd say (not ordered in any particular way)
-Plants v.s. Zombies
-Portal
-Half Life 2
-Fable (original/the lost chapters)
-Overlord
-Team Fortress 2
-Tetris (scratch that one, it's not recent enough)