shadylight said:
FMA Brotherhood
As you can see the things I find most appealing fall in a either a SoL that's mostly comedy shorts, or a philosophical/Psychological with some Action genre thrown in.
Well I am probably one of the biggest fans of the original Fullmetal Alchemist there is so I'd definitely give that a watch. It goes in a little more detail in the themes that are present in Brotherhood a little more effectively in my opinion. As well as the fact that the Homunculi are far more interesting in the original show, again this is just my opinion.
There is also Wolf's Rain. It has a lot of really good action and deals with themes that I personally find to be very fascinating. That and the dub for the show is nigh flawless in execution of dialogue and the creation of wonderful characters.
Berserk: If you can get over the baaaaaaaaaaad animation this show is really, really, REALLY good. It would be my all time favourite if not for the ending and the animation work in the show. Set in a medieval Europe it is a tragedy with very complex and memorable characters and deals with themes of fate, ambition, hubris, sacrifice and war.
EDIT: Oh by the way Happy first post!