What this guy said. While neither film is bad and in fact deviated greatly from the source material, actually read V for Vendetta, because it honestly sounds like you haven't. It's an excellent exploration of a facist society, the parallels between facism and anarchy, extremeism and tons of other themes I can't remember at present.molester jester said:OK condescending tone aside i was talking about the books yet you keep reverting the argument back to the films, my opinions of both films is relatively low i felt Children Of Men was handled badly and suffered from poor acting on Clive Owen's part. I was not that keen on the V for Vendetta movie either as they completely changed V and Evey's characters. Yet i still don't think you could really call V for Vendetta a child's book.BonsaiK said:You're making not one but two assumptions there.molester jester said:Touché but your entire post read like you have only watched the films, plus you seemed very dismissive of it being a comic book.BonsaiK said:No, it's just less meaningful because it's less meaningful.molester jester said:So just because it's a comic book it is less meaningful ?BonsaiK said:The underlying themes are identical. Children Of Men just does a far better job of exploring them. Children Of Men makes V For Vendetta look like exactly what it is - a film based on a comic book.j0frenzy said:I am guessing you are talking about the movie and not the book, but I don't really see how either are like V for Vendetta.BonsaiK said:Scrap V For Vendetta, try Children Of Men which is kinda the same thing, but for adults.
I repeat, V For Vendetta just isn't as good as Children Of Men. Period. Fullstop. The characters aren't as well fleshed-out or interesting, the story is relatively predictable, and the underlyring themes, while identical, are explored without as much depth (SOME, yes, but not as much). V For Vendetta is certainly not a bad film and is great for teenagers but anyone with a more adult type of brain is going to find some parts of it juvenile and will find Children Of Men to be a superior film.
So, in terms of the OP, none of them?SirBryghtside said:Really, because they're my favourite books, films and TV shows.
They're all comedy. Robert Rankin is hilarious, and his books are always compltely absurd, Tom Holt is a tiny bit more serious, and his books are very realistic, but with a fantasy element, e.g. Barking - it's a lawyer firm, competing with another firm.
It just so happens that one of the firms is full of werewolves, and the other vampires. He also has a Douglas Adams-esque mastery of similes.
Hot Fuzz is my favourite film, because it manages to be a hilarious comedy, has awesome action scenes, and has, unlike other comedies, got a serious undertone. Shaun of the Dead is much the same, and the unreleased Sci-fi one will undoubtedly follow on from that.
Buffy I sort of put in on an impulse, as it is a 'classic' pseudo-horror drama thing - it's not scary in the slightest, but is really good fun.
/Threadj0z said:I have to say 1984, everyone needs to read it, especially all members of the government.
Wow, that is pretty awesome. Doubleplus good indeed.Sampler said:/Threadj0z said:I have to say 1984, everyone needs to read it, especially all members of the government.
A surrealist movement mailed everyone at the Houses of Parlimant in the UK a copy of this on bonfire night last year (or the year before, time is a concept I'm only vaguely aware of), attached to it was a note:
This is a work of fiction, not a manual.
Doubleplus good I say..
Definitely Discworld.Beatrix said:I agree with V for Vendetta.
And Discworld, all of it.
Good book!Trivun said:Book: Z For Zachariah.
Funny you should mention that, I was really into fantasy stuff (the genre, not the thoughts that take up about 3/4 of my time in class) in middle school and high school, and I read the whole Autumn/Winter/Spring trilogy (if I remember right). Good stuff.The Cake Is A Lie said:Dragonlance: Chronicles
They released a Summer book a few years later (Summer Flame) that happens years after the Spring book ended. I read the Chronicles Trilogy when I was in middle school as well, and it ended up being my favourite fantasy seriessetvak said:Funny you should mention that, I was really into fantasy stuff (the genre, not the thoughts that take up about 3/4 of my time in class) in middle school and high school, and I read the whole Autumn/Winter/Spring trilogy (if I remember right). Good stuff.The Cake Is A Lie said:Dragonlance: Chronicles