Let me get this straight, the main issue that this review brings up is that the game's story and situations don't make sense and that the combat is repetitive?
If you ask me, and that is a big if, you shouldn't play video games for their story line. For that kind of stuff just watch a movie or read a book, seriously, stories in those are infinitely better than any video game has ever pulled off.
And for the repetive part, it's a really subjective matter. I mean, you don't get more repetitive than Tetris and somehow millions upon millions don't find that annoying at all.