Not trying to sound tough, but i don't really get scared by games.. supprize-shock sure.
In RE4 when that big monster in the lake ate me off the pier... that was not arGH WTF!?!?
Also in RE4, when you run around the small underground hall beeing chased by one of the renniscance-gnome-dudes creepy twin-minions which you cannot kill, thats the creepiest part of any game i've been through, but nothing scary as in I felt afraid afterwards.
In RE4 when that big monster in the lake ate me off the pier... that was not arGH WTF!?!?
Also in RE4, when you run around the small underground hall beeing chased by one of the renniscance-gnome-dudes creepy twin-minions which you cannot kill, thats the creepiest part of any game i've been through, but nothing scary as in I felt afraid afterwards.