The Wykydtron said:
The damn Giant Ants in Fallout 3... That scuttling sound that they make really scares me. Yes they're low level but they are fucking scary when you don't know where they are.
That one dungeon near Megaton, the school that has a nest of them underneath it. I fucking had to leg it out of there in a blind panic just because I couldn't find the last few ants that were making that infernal noise.
Probably because they just made the noise continue anyway after all the ants are dead just to freak you out. It was an entire nest of them after all.
Also Mirelurks, fucking scary bastards. Yet I oddly enjoyed the mission where you have to sneak into a lair to plant a beacon amongst their eggs without killing any of them. Y'know a Mirelurk hater's worst nightmare. Funny that.
I think good scary sections in non-horror games are worse than the scares in actual horror games. Like you don't expect it to just go bam! Scary section activate! At least in horror games you know what you're getting yourself into.
Oh I...mmm....those damn ants...I....*shakes head.* I just recently seriously got into Fallout 3 and those fuckers piss me off so much. The sound they make drives me crazy. Have you been to grayditch? I won't say anymore in case you haven't, but that section...I had more jump scares because of those...and I died SO many times.
As for scariest moment...I have to agree with the OP because that's as far as my scary gaming goes, the dark cave in Fable 3. I just can't stand playing horror and scary games. I tried playing Bioshock because it did seem really cool...and quit within about ten minutes because it was putting me too much on edge. But I can watch playthroughs with little to no upset.