necromanzer52 said:
IncredibleKoosh said:
Metal Gear Solid. Can be finished in around 3 hours - but it's perfect. And so good that you'll play it again. And again. And again.
Isn't that game on multiple discs? With cutscenes up to an hour in length?
I've been putting off getting into this series due to its size, but if the first game is short enough, I'll try it out.
You could, in all honesty, just play the first one and never touch the others. You don't miss out on anything as the original game had NO gods-damned hangups, anime overtones, or any of that other crap that continuously showed up in the sequels. I love it to this day but could never play the sequels a second time.
Anyways, I think I'll make the obligatory Portal mention. However, beyond that it's hard to think of good examples. You can't really say stuff like Illusion of Gaia because they weren't really short at the time, though they are by today's standards.
Portal - Even though it took me about 12 hours to beat it the first time, I can easily beat it in under 7 on replays. The immersion was splendid, I kept wanting to know what was gonna happen next, and the puzzles were quite good.
Actraiser - Short, even by the standards of other games from that time period, it nonetheless was an enthralling game where you wanted to get the max population on all the cities. It is still a shock that the sequel removed that feature as it was, in my opinion, what made the game great.
Jolly Rover - Even though it borrows a bit from Monkey Island, it was still a unique twist on a familiar concept. The characters were endearing and I genuinely found myself wanting more after I'd finished it. I actually wrote in to the guy who made it asking if there would be a second one, but unfortunately he admitted it didn't sell well enough for them to get the go ahead. Maybe it if had sold more copies...
MegaMan 2 & 3 - Fairly short for their time, though insanely fun and addicting. I'd actually stick MegaMan 1 in this, but it wasn't as good as 2 or 3 in my opinion (which is what you're asking for). In fact, 2 and 3 are the only ones I will play frequently as I still feel they're the best of the Classic series.
Tail Concerto - Although rather short for a PSX game, it nonetheless captured my attention. I liked the characters a lot, especially the kittens, and the gameplay was really good. I'd always hoped for a sequel, but never heard of one. You really got the feeling you were in a series of ruins in the sky..
Mister Mosquito - I know, it's a quirky game and a lot of people haven't played it.. while I was, admittedly, a little tired of the gameplay by the end of the game (cause the difficulty skyrocketed) I kept wanting to get more of the storyline. I heard they'd made a sequel, but we never got it. The humour was very good in the game and it was very unique.
Hmm.. I wanna list others but they're either not that short (in my opinion), or weren't short when they came out. :/