So I just realized I'm a terrible person...

Shotgun_Ninja

New member
Jun 2, 2009
31
0
0
Yeah, this is going to be a long one, so, right to it; I'm 24 I've been in a serious relationship with this girl(22) for the last three years. She's a great person and is wholeheartedly in love with me. As time progressed I realized I didn't reciprocate those feelings, and broke up her. She was heartbroken, and even though I felt like a bastard for hurting her, I took solace with the fact that at least I ended it properly, face-to-face and did my best to make her understand it wasn't her fault, that I just felt we weren't meant to be.

Three months go by, I'm fine. She's fine. We even still talked occasionally on the phone, as friends. Then suddenly, after months of being perfectly content and dating around and not being in a dedicated relationship, I see her out with someone else. My inner jealous douchebag takes over and I decide I need to get her back.

After a week of calling, texting and damn near begging (pathetic, I know) we get back together and all is right with the world... until I remember why I broke up with her in the first place (that is to say, inherent incompatibility issues i.e. she tends to get on my nerves all the damn time).

Cut to a couple of weeks ago when some friends and I go out to a club to see a local band. I meet this girl, we start talking and hitting it off. She's 25, beautiful, Intelligent and extremely well-read (she's actually an 11th grade english teacher!) with a great sense of humor and taste in music and movies. Oh, and she loves football. It's like she was created in a lab to be awesome. We exchange numbers. We hang out a few days later at a friend's house and are up to 4:00am drinking and talking about music. Now I can't stop thinking about her, but I'm in a relationship with a girl who loves me to death, and whom I've already hurt once.

Basically, I'm a child who doesn't know what he wants.

Thoughts?
 

S.R.S.

New member
Nov 3, 2009
2,007
0
0

Sorry it's all I could think about.

Ask BonsaiK, he's the relationship advice guy around here.
 

Kragg

New member
Mar 30, 2010
730
0
0
atleast you realised you are that guy?

no real way to comfort you, it is a fairly common thing. i have friends that are that guy, my brother is that guy, i might have been that guy at some point!

(funny how you said you broke her up, the violence :D)
 

Woodsey

New member
Aug 9, 2009
14,553
0
0
Meh, dump the one you're with now. You fucked up, now get on with it.

Besides, everyone wants to bang thefit English teacher - now you get the chance!
 

Robert632

New member
May 11, 2009
3,870
0
0
No matter what you do you're fucked, so at least get out of the relationship you don't want to be in.
 

Latinidiot

New member
Feb 19, 2009
2,215
0
0
bah, you are fucked. Nothing can go right from now on, so you might as well pick the one that's the least wrong for you.
 

steevee

New member
Apr 16, 2008
327
0
0
Yeah, I'd say hurt the girl you hurt already. You're gunna do it at some point in the future anyway.

And the other girl sounds awsome.
 

Evil the White

New member
Apr 16, 2009
918
0
0
Well done, you screwed up. Again.

Do what you feel is right. Just remember what you've done so you don't do it again.
 

MiracleOfSound

Fight like a Krogan
Jan 3, 2009
17,776
0
0
Dump her now, the longer you wait the worse the poor girl's heart is going to be broken.

By the way, it's guys like you who give the rest of us a bad name.
 

razer17

New member
Feb 3, 2009
2,518
0
0
Yeah, it's a bit of a dick move. Okay, a big dick move. But if you string her along now, you'll hurt her more than if you do it now. Sure, you will probably never talk again, but it's better to be with someone you like, otherwise it just ends badly for both of you.
 

Ekit

New member
Oct 19, 2009
1,183
0
0
I'd say wait until you know who you want.

Also, do you know if the teacher likes you the same way? Maybe she doesn't...
 

SonicWaffle

New member
Oct 14, 2009
3,019
0
0
MiracleOfSound said:
Dump her now, the longer you wait the worse the poor girl's heart is going to be broken.

By the way, it's guys like you who give the rest of us a bad name.
Nah, I think that'd be all the rapists, chauvinists, cheating bastards and so on. At least this dude is aware he fucked up, and is trying to avoid hurting anyone.

Unfortunately life doesn't work that way; you've gotten yourself into a situation where someone is going to get hurt. Do you want it to be you, spending all your time with someone you don't love? Do you want it to be your girlfriend, a while down the line when she discovers you don't care for her? Or do you want to hurt this awesome new girl who is apparently perfect for you?

Your choice, bro. If it were me I'd lose the girlfriend.
 

Soluncreed

New member
Sep 24, 2009
482
0
0
You're only going to end up hurting her more if you break up with her later because she will realize that you had been making her unhappy. You're not a terrible person for making a mistake as long as you learn from it. Just break up with her and get with the new girl no matter how much it pains your current girlfriend.
 

Mechsoap

New member
Apr 4, 2010
2,129
0
0
the first girl you know and love, and she loves you with all her hearth...and there is a greater change with the first girl i think
 

EeveeElectro

Cats.
Aug 3, 2008
7,055
0
0
Wow, people on here had too many ***** flakes this morning.

I've heard that happen so many times, even if you fell out of love with your ex, you still feel jealous when you see they've moved on because that's the happiness you want again most likely. It's just human nature.
It was a bad idea to get back with her just because you were jealous, you should have just moved on, it's very unlikely it would work out with an ex. They're an ex for a reason.
You should finish your girlfriend instead of stringing her on for longer and let her find a boyfriend who will appreciate her. This other girl sounds fabulous, and a nice match for you. I've always said you can't pick who you fall in love with; I left my ex for my current boyfriend and I've never been happier.
I'll be the first to tell you you're not a terrible person, just unfortunate circumstances. You're actually considering her feelings, if you thought, "Yeah! I'd string them both along!" then you'd be a dick.
 

xsosxfelix

Demon
Jun 15, 2010
30
0
0
dude i had this same problem about two years a go only i stayed with the girl I'd already hurt, we got married and have a small family now and life is good, but i don't love her as much as i think a married couple should and I'm always wondering, what if? my advice? break up with the first chick and keep looking.