So, lets talk about racism for a minute

[Natasha_LB]

Unfortunately it's one of the few ways you can integrate a previously segregated people into what is considered normal society.

I don't think so. All that racism does is encourage the favoured group into a learned helplessness dependancy on those benefits, while at the structural level, nothing changes.

It's just fighting a symptom while the underlying problems remain, or even, get worse. Because the resentment you talked of is true, so the conclusion should be that affirmative action type racism only worsens the situation.

Yeah right, it'll make things worse.... because granting people who have been discriminated against a tiny bit of the privilege that others have enjoyed for years, would be silly: Whereas if the majority group have the privilege (Both in the past and now), then that's fine is it?

I'll make this really simple for you... Imagine you got given a bag of 10 cookies, you were supposed to share them out equally with a minority group... but you didn't. You chose instead to have nine all to yourself, while kicking the minority in the face. Now your on the last cookie, and because of how you behaved in the past, someone else has taken charge of the cookies and is giving the last one to the minority... and your saying that that's not fair?

Not even that, but your claiming that it will "encourage the minority into a learned helplessness dependency on those benefits". Are you sure about that? Because the majority are doing pretty well right now as a result of those benefits: They are certainly not helpless!! So why would giving the minority group, a little bit of privilege for once be a bad thing! Something tells me that you're just worried about losing your own privilege. You don't want to stand on equal ground with everyone else.

Well you know what to go back to the metaphor: Give them the last cookie all to themselves, because you've already had nine!! After that apologize to them, and make sure that you share the next bag!

Neither is it needed to avoid anything. For one thing, I remember aboriginals in Australia showing ramping rates of alcoholism and child abuse. Both those wreck a community. What needs changing in that case is the culture which enables that; how come it's normal to drink or screw or beat your own children? How come such a thing goes unnoticed, unchanged or unpunished?

Okay, the child abuse side of things I cant comment on, what I can say is that minorities have a much harder time of it in life than you could ever imagine: I feel scared leaving my house for a cigarette, because of the amount of times I've been beaten up, and that fear has driven me to drink like hell, just so I can manage the walk to work. It is not the culture that cause alcoholism, rather the simple fact that the rest of the world treats minorities like shit!

I'm not sure if that level of stress and fear could contribute to the high levels of abuse, but it wouldn't surprise me. It can certainly fuck with someone's mental well being, and that could well lead to abuse. It doesn't excuse them from what they do, but it does explain it.

You however, rather that looking at the way the majority is oppressing the minority, and seeing that the oppression could be influencing their behaviour, seem to think that because of their behaviour, they need to be oppressed even more.

Where I'm from, in the 80's, if you stepped on a bicycle on sunday, people would throw rocks at you, pull you off and assault you. By the 90's this had stopped and didn't occur anymore. How come? Because the culture changed. The extremist religious denomination (reformists) which controls a large part of the village lost power, the police stopped tolerating religious violence, a new generation of reformists was slightly less extremist gained more prominence in that decade due to aging and people from elsewhere with normal values also moved in bit by bit.

That hardly counts, no one forced you to ride a bike on a Sunday, don't get me wrong: It's still fucked up, but you knew what to do in order to avoid it. I on the other hand have to put up with shit like this every signal day, whenever I leave my house. You may have been through some shit: I'm not denying that, but suffering what sounds like a fairly small amount of religious discrimination that was easy to avoid (By the sounds of it - just don't ride a bike on Sunday), is a world away from what a lot of us go through. I've been hospitalized 4 times this year, because I committed the terrible crime of walking down the street. Your entire post has indicated that you do not understand what it's like to be a minority.

Being an aboriginal as it is now must not be preserved. That identity is constructed from a primitive culture that doesn't belong in this age, added by years of conflicts with another group, years of apathy from losing those conflicts, hostility, marginalisation and learned helplessness.
It is a bad identity and it has to die. It has to die out and become extinct, a thing of the past, and all the problems that came with it will die with it too.

Right, Aboriginals right now "must not" be preserved, they're "primitive", and "don't belong in this age".... that's not fucked up at all. It's certainly not racist.... oh wait, yes it fucking is. What the hell are you on about?? I suppose next you'll be saying that being black as it is now can't be preserved!?

What the hell are you taking? If you think that's okay to say, and is not incredibly racist and offensive, then I assume that you will not take offence at this statement: "Blablahb must not be preserved, he's primitive and does not belong in this age".

It's not nice to read is it? Kinda stings a little, so don't you dare do it to other people. And next time you make a post CHECK YOUR F***ING PRIVILEGE!!!

 

[Natasha_LB]

Yeah right, it'll make things worse.... because granting people who have been discriminated against a tiny bit of the privilege that others have enjoyed for years, would be silly: Whereas if the majority group have the privilege (Both in the past and now), then that's fine is it?

Do two wrongs make a right?

Two wrongs do certainly not make a right, however some some wrongs have existed for far longer than others. Minority groups deserve a leg up, because of how much we have been (And still are) pushed down. I'm all for eliminating discrimination, but while negative discrimination still exists, then positive discrimination is not a bad thing. Positive discrimination is a poor attempt at solving the problem, a mere bandage on a wound that needs stitching, but don't take the bandage off, just get the god damn stitches!! Because right now, that bandage is the only thing stopping the wound from bleeding out (A bad metaphor I know, as the bandage would need to be removed before the stitches could be placed, but I'm sure you understand my point - negative discrimination must be dealt with before positive discrimination)

As for "making a right", you don't seem at all interested in that, you just seem to want to ensure that minorities never have any advantage, no matter how small, over you. Interesting how someone who is in a position of privilege wants to stop other from gaining even footing... What are you worried about? Are you scared that without some of your pre-existing and unearned advantages that you might not be able to maintain your position in society? Worried that some of us minorities might actually be better than you, and if the oppression was removed some of us might actually surpass you? (Just to be clear, I'm not suggesting that I'm personally better than you - neither of us know enough about the other to make such a judgement yet - but it's inevitable that one of the people you're oppressing will be better than you in every possible way)

That hardly counts, no one forced you to ride a bike on a Sunday, don't get me wrong: It's still fucked up, but you knew what to do in order to avoid it. I on the other hand have to put up with shit like this every signal day, whenever I leave my house.

I'm pretty sure that you A are vastly exagerating, and B could avoid whatever negative contacts you've had, if you tried according to your own ideas of avoiding.

I'm pretty sure if a race war had broken out in the UK, the media would've picked up about it by now, so I'm not going to believe you.

Neither am I going to get into your lame attempts at calling me a racist because you disagree with me, but can't refute what I say because you know I'm right.

A race war has not broken out in the UK, at least not to my knowledge, and I have never claimed that I have suffered any form of racial discrimination: It would be odd if I have as I am white, and was born in this country. I recognize that in that regard I am very lucky, and that I have privilege because of that. I can never understand fully what it is like to be discriminated for racial reasons, however I do know what it is like to be oppressed.

I simply said that I am a member of a minority group. A group that sadly still faces high levels of discrimination, and revives very little press coverage about it. I am scared to leave my house alone, or even to step outside for a smoke alone, because of things that have happened to me in the past. I am scared to contact the police when things go badly, because not once have they ever helped, and on several occasions have only discriminated against me further.

You think I can avoid the discrimination I face? You're having a laugh, I can't even leave the house alone, let alone get a job. I go everywhere with my partner, and If I can't go with her, then my friends will go out for me to buy me food. I do what work I can from home, but it's not much of an income: I live in the poorest area of the UK. Avoiding riding a bike is simple, being hungry for days because there is no one who can hook me up with food, and I'm too scared to go out for it alone it a little different, so don't even dare to try and compare our experiences.

And I have never said that you are a racist, not once. Please try to quote where I said that? Really, try it! All I have said is that you are part of a majority that oppresses a minority, sometimes purposefully, sometimes unknowingly, and in your case through ignorance. I truly believe that you do not realize what you do, or that realize how bad things still are for some people. That's why I asked you to check your privilege. Did you do it?

You have to realize that simply by being alive, the majority help contribute to discrimination unless they actively fight it. Denying that it exists as you have done is even worse. You are an oppressor, denying it only makes you worse.

One more time: CHECK YOUR PRIVILEGE!!!

Oh, and you're last comment, I refute completely what you say, and not only do I think your views are pretty fucking stupid, I have also provided several strong arguments that show that. You are an oppressor, and I'm starting to wonder if you're doing that through ignorance, or if you know exactly what you're doing, and you keep on doing it because you want to remain in your position at the top.

 

[Gigano]

Affirmative action is never acceptable, insofar as it targets people who've had no hand in causing any inequalities.

It's simple state sponsored racism/sexism, trampling on the rights of individuals who've never done anything to those they're being discriminated in favour of. There a bound to be majority individuals who're equally disadvantaged, and when the criteria for help is not "disadvantage" but "race/sex", then the state is actively discriminating those... and the people whom AA favour happily profiting off that discrimination. Only the individual economic situation of each person can ever be a reasonable criteria of government aid. If that turns out to overall favour certain groups whom those individuals belong to, that's totally fine: So long as those in other groups with equal needs are given equal treatment.

It might suck that history have left some groups in overall poorer straits, but just as sexual abuse in no way gives the abused any right to continue the circle, groups which have suffered in the past have absolutely no justification for discriminating innocent people who never had any hand in that.

Supporters of AA are simply racists/sexists who believe that the colour of their skin or their sex should give them special benefits over others who never did anything to them, and should be treated as such.

 

[GistoftheFist]

There's a pretty good Cracked article that came out today, anyone who says how whites 'screwed' the natives should read it: http://www.cracked.com/article_19864_6-ridiculous-lies-you-believe-about-founding-america.html

 

[jewamongyou]

Re; Jojo and the skulls.

Your "head shot" regarding the two skulls turns out to have missed the target completely. Your Spanish blog source is badly mistaken - and it is not the original source, as you contend. Here, read this:

http://www.canovan.com/HumanOrigin/PINTUBI-1/PINTUBI-1.htm

Now you can lick your wounds, knowing that you've mistaken an Australoid skull for a Neanderthal one.