I'm a huge Nintendo fan and love Mario but while I like the idea Mario Maker has never really piqued my interest. The idea of a Mario level editor is great, but actually playing the levels it would feel to me like you're only getting half the experience of a Mario game. For me Mario isn't just about the platforming, it's also the 'World' aspect finding all those secrets and getting 100% completion.
So basically what would get me really excited is Super Mario World Maker.
So basically what would get me really excited is Super Mario World Maker.