Update - finished Dead Space, still co-op playing Dead Island.
Also played ep. 1 of The Walking Dead.
It was ok-ish. I haven't played an adventure game in forever, and the thing turned out to be insultingly easy. Half the stuff you say doesn't matter, and the other half doesn't matter either, since all it does is get you slightly different dialogue in return. Trust and mistrust is built I suppose, "X will remember that" and whatever, but at the end of the day the script is too tight to allow much divergence, so that it's not so much as Choose Your Own Adventure as it is another David Cage game (with more endearing characters, fair enough). The puzzle-play is insultingly easy too so all you're really left with is a visual novel with a few action QTEs thrown in for good measure.