Aliens: Defiance (3/5)
Defiance is probably the closest we're going to get to an Aliens TV series, in as much that it's how it's structured (12 issues covering a single story, whereas most Aliens graphic novels are shorter and more focused on a particular incident. If that's the case however, then it's kind of emblematic of a problem with the Aliens/Predator IP, and that's that you can only do so much with the concept.
Story takes place in 2137/38, and follows Zula Hendrics (a former marine) and Davis 01 - an android that goes rogue, wanting to wipe out all xenos for the sake of humanity. Already, there's a bit of an issue here, and it's been an issue for awhile - the movies operated under the premise that the xenomorph is more or less confined to LV-426 as a point of origin. Here however, the things are everywhere, and the Company is experimenting on them. Now, if the Aliens IP wants to have a paradigm where xenomorphs are literally everywhere, and going anywhere in the galaxy means you're risking danger, that's fine, but it's a paradigm that doesn't gel well with the films. But even casting that aside, what we have is okay. It's frankly better handled than a lot of Aliens stories, in that with fewer characters to focus on, they get to be fleshed out more, along with better worldbuilding. Like, nothing major, but we see a bit of what life is like on Earth for the people of the early 22nd century. It's grim, but not grimdark grim. Perhaps intentionally, it's depicted as being quite similar to our own, and that includes levels of technology. Yeah, we can fly around in starships, but helicopters are still used in atmosphere for instance.
There's another issue though, and that's that the Colonial Marines are shown to be in cahoots with WY, and by the end of the story, WY manages to retrieve some xenomorph DNA (and in the sequel series, show how it's used). What I'm left to ask then is why WY is so insinstent on still catching xenomorphs further down the line, and why the Marines are so in the dark in the titular Aliens films when here, marines are deployed with full knowledge of the xenomorph and how to handle it.
Anyway, it's decent, but ultimately hampered by the IP it's set in.