Sure most of that is true, except no. He didn't crack down on anything that wasn't puritan. He championed religious freedom. MasterOfHisOwnDomain was right about the reforms he made. There was a state church under his rule, but no-one was forced to attend and Catholics and Jews were able to worship how they wished. Oh and he didn't ban Christmas, although he did back a law that would have down played the celebrations of Saints days and Christmas, but his minority government had trouble passing it and it was widely ignored.BlackStar42 said:Gonna have to disagree with you there. He was a brutal dictator and a religious fanatic who cracked down on anything that wasn't Puritan. The fucker even banned Christmas. That's pretty low. Oh, and there was the small matter of wiping out 30% of the Irish population. He gets the title "Butcher" for a very good reason.MasterOfHisOwnDomain said:For the United Kingdom:
- Oliver Cromwell. His policies on religious freedom and reform of the law / Parliament were incredibly ahead of their time. It took until the Great Reform Act of 1832 to re-establish what Cromwell had set up during his reign.
I agree he was one of my favourite pms of australia.octafish said:jPaul Keating is my choice. Arrogant, abusive, combatative, brilliant, and commited to his ideals. He is the only Australian leader to have inspired a successful musical. For proof of his brilliance I'd like to post his Redfern speech but I can't work out how to grab the youtube info with my phone.
By the way Poms, are you forgeting Benjamin Disraeli?
I know this is a few posts late ( 4 pages... ) but honestly, I agree with him - I'd want a guy like Hitler to run our country if we ended up in that kind of position. Don't get me wrong, what he did was wrong - but his Charisma, his leadership and his ability to turn a crippled Germany into an economic superpower capable of fighting on four fronts? You've got to admire the leadership there. What I don't agree with is his treatment of the ethnic and religious groups - killing them was inhumane and hoenstly evil. You give me a leader like hitler, without the racial superiority complex; I'd vote for him.SmashLovesTitanQuest said:His treatment of the Germans after WW2 was rather horrid. He wanted to kill everyone.Sixcess said:How so?SmashLovesTitanQuest said:Winston Churchill was a fucking criminal. Almost as bad as the leaders of the axis.
[sub]I have the feeling this thread will soon be moving to the religion and politics sub-forum...[/sub]
Every leader in WW2 was a fucking scumbag, on both sides, and every one of them did their fair share of atrocities, be it executing jews, sending jews to Germany to be executed, torturing prisoners.... Which is why it pisses me off when one of them is portrayed as a hero. People need to fucking wake up and realize neither Churchill nor Hitler were heros.
EDIT: Just an example of what a fucking nutjob Churchill was: after the second world war he said that if one day England found itself in an economic slump simular to the one Germany found themselves in before Hitler took over, he would want a man like Hitler to lead Britain. Lovely.
Going to disagree with all that:BlackStar42 said:Gonna have to disagree with you there. He was a brutal dictator and a religious fanatic who cracked down on anything that wasn't Puritan. The fucker even banned Christmas. That's pretty low. Oh, and there was the small matter of wiping out 30% of the Irish population. He gets the title "Butcher" for a very good reason.
This. So glad to have been able to study him.octafish said:I find Cromwell fascinating, full of contradictions and surprises, and not quite as brutal a monster as history would have you believe.
Yup, the guy who banned most sports, make-up, doing anything on a Sunday, celebrating on Christmas, and subjugated and murdered a bunch of Irish people after saying they wouldn't be harmed and turned their children into slaves for no reason other than he assumed all Irish Catholics were traitors was a brilliant leader. That's why the minute he was out of power the monarchy was restored.MasterOfHisOwnDomain said:For the United Kingdom:
- Oliver Cromwell. His policies on religious freedom and reform of the law / Parliament were incredibly ahead of their time. It took until the Great Reform Act of 1832 to re-establish what Cromwell had set up during his reign.
I'll agree with that. I just wish that Gough's free uni stuff had stuck around longer.solidsnake101023 said:Who are your favourite leaders who were the head of the country you live in or are from.
Gough Whitlam introduced free health care, free education, destroyed conscription and gave women equal pay.
John Curtin saved us during World War 2.
Paul Keating man was hilarious.
He never said the Irish wouldn't be harmed; he made it perfectly clear he intended to make them pay for their uprising against the English that partly caused the English Civil War. Subjugating Ireland was not Cromwell's bright idea, he was merely the most successful person at it - thus making him a brilliant leader.Chairman Miaow said:Yup, the guy who banned most sports, make-up, doing anything on a Sunday, celebrating on Christmas, and subjugated and murdered a bunch of Irish people after saying they wouldn't be harmed and turned their children into slaves for no reason other than he assumed all Irish Catholics were traitors was a brilliant leader. That's why the minute he was out of power the monarchy was restored.
Regardless of why he did it or whether or not people did it before him, Cromwell committed genocide. And when I say wouldn't be harmed, I'm talking in particular about the siege of Drogheda and the sack of Wexford, where he most certainly did promise they wouldn't be harmed.MasterOfHisOwnDomain said:He never said the Irish wouldn't be harmed; he made it perfectly clear he intended to make them pay for their uprising against the English that partly caused the English Civil War. Subjugating Ireland was not Cromwell's bright idea, he was merely the most successful person at it - thus making him a brilliant leader.Chairman Miaow said:Yup, the guy who banned most sports, make-up, doing anything on a Sunday, celebrating on Christmas, and subjugated and murdered a bunch of Irish people after saying they wouldn't be harmed and turned their children into slaves for no reason other than he assumed all Irish Catholics were traitors was a brilliant leader. That's why the minute he was out of power the monarchy was restored.
The monarchy was restored because there was a power struggle after his death between his Parliament and the Army. Richard Cromwell resigned the position of Lord Protector, and the Army kicked out Parliament. Then things started to fall apart, and the General in charge of order in Scotland came down with the only held-together army and returned the King to power - for lack of imagination.
That's why the monarchy was restored not because "Cromwell was a bad man". Which he wasn't.