Jennacide said:
I'd tend to say Aqua Teen Hunger Force personifies Adult Swim's bizarre sensibilities better than Venture Bros. The comedy in ATHF is absurd and yet usually understandable (but not always). And yet there is a series of meta gags running around the show, like it's newer insistance that it is NOT ATHF anymore, but Aqua Unit Patrol Squad One, or Aqua TV Show Show, or my favorite "Aqua Something You Know, Whatever..." ATHF also speaks volumes about comedy when the show is about a 'family' of talking food products living next to a stereotypically white trash neighbor, and that is the least crazy part of any single episode. With story arcs like Shake being turned into a chocolate milkshake by being bitten by a radioactive black man; or a walking sentient dick that makes everything out of dicks and has appeared multiple times as different characters, such as BALLOON HITLER (Der Inflatable Fuhrer).
I'd say a good chunk of what you're feeling is nostalgia goggles. I shotgunned the whole series this past summer, and somewhere around 85% of it was a steaming bag of dog excrement. Then again, your claim was that it personified Adult Swim's typical programming, and that still fits with my claim... Parts of it were absolutely brilliant, but you had to wade through a whole lot of crap after the first couple of seasons to get to another good joke. Or watch Carl's Stone Cold Lock of the Century, of the Week. That probably could have become an institution and I'd have no problems with it, and I don't even care much for sports. It is a show whose viewing is dramatically improved by only watching the clips that have been uploaded on youtube.
Conversely, Venture Bros must be watched all the way through, and gets better with repeat viewings. So much stuff that happens in later episodes was mentioned offhandedly in an earlier episode. It's building a brick wall of mythos, and they just keep adding more layers. It would not surprise me to find out that the reason they're taking so long with production is that they have to keep making sure that they never contradict themselves. It's character development like Bob mentioned in his American Dad episode, except Venture Bros is one overarching narrative.
Also, as someone who's watched a lot of "Everybody Loves Raymond", I found the first season of Eagleheart to be amazing. Have not been able to watch the rest.
However, I disagree with live programming on Adult Swim in principle. Adult Swim is the late night Cartoon Network programming block, a channel that USED to be cartoons 24/7. They've been gradually moving away from what defines their network, and the logo is now the initials; it feels like MTV all over again...