Moviebob, if ever I meet you in person, we HAVE to talk about the Critic, and then quote the show in full sentences. I love the Critic.
I used to watch the show when I was very young (I want to say four or five, and it was usually on around the time of the Simpsons, and my parents loved the Simpsons, so I could stay up and watch it). It sort of fueled me and my love for movies very early on. I couldn't get a lot of the jokes, but even at a very young age, I got quite a bit of the movie jokes (Rabbi P.I. is the most prominent joke I could recall from a young age) then I did the more adult jokes. I got the series on DVD when I was 16 (My grandfather bought it for me before he died, too. It's the last gift I got from him) and loved it.
Jon Lovitz is a great actor, singer and above all else, unrealized performer. I wish he'd got more roles in films than the bit role in an Adam Sandler movie he gets thrown every once in a while. In fact, I'm having a stroke of good luck here in the last week, and I found myself humming "Nothing's gonna stop me now" from the episode "Jay & Siskel & Ebert & Alice". Still got it.
The Critic was important to the 90s, even if we didn't really realize its potential at the time, but it was still funny and great to watch, and I'm in the same camp as you that Season 2 wasn't anywhere near as good as Season 1 (Alice, love her to death, she's the only one Jay's ever called a superfreak) but it did have its high points, being that Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert making an appearance after previously panning it on their show was stunning, and still cool to see it happen, although at that point in the series, the animations became incredibly lazy (you could tell when the animators just looped parts after awhile, as evidenced around maybe the last three or four episodes, especially in the final episode clip show).
At the end of the day, I love the Critic. I own the series on DVD and I quote it in spades. Great episode, Moviebob.