Netrigan said:
Lightknight said:
From what I understand, people were demonized, positions were taken in the article. All on Zoe's side.
He criticized the TV people, not the gaming folks. JonTron and Zoe had some kind of disagreement, which was never specified and they took it outside to discuss it in private... and the cameras, desperate for conflict, tried to follow along. The game jam had sub-par equipment, lots of product placement, and lots of attempts to create drama, including bring in non-dev JonTron to be a part of it.
I'm not sure why it is relevant who is criticized and whether or not they were gamer community people. What if Zoe and co were being total tool-bags to people they'd signed contracts with as I was under the impression the TV crew had stated?
Let me ask you this, why do you think Stephen Totilo deemed the questions important enough to issue a public statement that Nathan Grayson had not started a relationship with her before the kotaku article had gone live?
"Nathan has been accused of in some way trading positive coverage of a developer for the opportunity to sleep with her, of failing to disclose that he was in a romantic relationship with a developer he had written about, and that he'd given said developer's game a favorable review. All of those are troubling claims that we take seriously. All would be violations of the standards we maintain." [http://kotaku.com/in-recent-days-ive-been-asked-several-times-about-a-pos-1624707346]
Now, I don't believe Nathan or Zoe were actually exchanging love fluids for anything. I think they were just interested in eachother as people do. Frankly, you'd have to prove some sort of agreement of exchange for me to believe they'd don otherwise.
However, "Failing to disclose that he was in a romantic relationship with a developer he had written about" was absolutely breached. 100%.
The "developer's game a favorable review" was also true but not at kotaku and likely not when they were in a romantic relationship. Or, at least, there's no evidence that there was any relationship in 2013 when he was placed in the credits of the game as a tester. That was a breach because it was a game he was involved in testing and there was a friendly relationship there. Zoe actually called him a Beta Tester. So this is still a serious conflict of interest.
Look, you may not care about journalistic integrity but the industry does and want to maintain a legitimate degree of professional journalism. Disclosing conflicts of interest is vital to a trustworthy news source.
I wonder if Totilo is aware that they had a romantic relationship before the article went live?