ardias014 said:
1st off: I agree with you on leaving choice open for earlier games, but that isn't validation. True validation in this circumstance would mean it literaly put your choice in the next game.
2: MK misses the gigantic plot hole of Lorkhan being dead and having his body ripped into pieces and the other thousand problems with the conflicting lore.
3: But was pelinal insane every second. No. Just because Akatosh has madness doesn't mean he is the god of chaos or insanity. Everything is at least partially mad or insane.
Also:"It is said that Pelinal emerged in to Nirn like a Padomaic, carried by Sithis and all other forces of change. Described by Morihaus as an ada or spirit, Pelinal plays the same role as a long line of avatars sent by Shor to champion the cause of mankind. Pelinal, however, is an exception, as he exhibits significant bonds to Akatosh as well, who is hostile to Shor."
4: Thanks for clearing that up Sithis always confused me because they say hes a hole in reality sometimes.
1. True validation only means they told you what you did happened, which they do in the ES series. You are confusing validation of choice with follow-through of choice.
.
.
2. All the gods are dead, they all died at the creation of the mortal world.
http://uesp.net/wiki/Lore:The_Monomyth - "Finally, the magical beings of Mythic Aurbis told the ultimate story -- that of their own death. "
Lorkhan only had his heart removed, his body wasn't torn up.
Also there is no conflict in the lore, both Oblivion AND Skyrim visually show that Akatosh is Lorkhan and vice-versa. I will explain it to you if you desire, but it is quite long.
Furthermore having your heart torn out means nothing abut your ability to do stuff. Just because Akatosh who is Lorkhan is dead and has had his heart removed does not prevent him from being able to appear manifest and fight Dagon and do other things.
-Look at Sithis, he has a giant gaping hole in his chest, and has his heart removed, because Sithis and Lorkhan are the same being, and he still gets around to ruling the Dark Brotherhood and taking souls. http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20111111090058/elderscrolls/images/3/3e/700889-sithis_super.jpg
-Zurin Arctus also had a hole blown in his chest and has his heart destroyed, by the original underking, and still managed to live for many years as the second underking
http://uesp.net/wiki/Lore:The_Arcturian_Heresy - "With his last breath, the Underking's Heart roars a hole through the Battlemage's chest."
-Pelinal whitestrake also had a hole in his chest and was missing a heart and was able to walk around killing stuff
http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Lore:The_Song_of_Pelinal,_v_6 - "Still others, like Fifd of New Teed, say that beneath the Pelinal's star-armor was a chest that gaped open to show no heart"
.
.
3. I never said Akatosh was a god of madness, only that he was mad.
Furthermore Akatosh and Shor are not hostile at all, Shor is hostile to Arui-el, but Auri-El is different then Akatosh. In fact Shor and his wife Kyne made an alliance with Kyranith and the other Imperial gods so they would wage war against the Elven gods.
Akatosh/Auri-El/Alkosh/Tosh Raka are all the same dragon-god of time yet each are separate individuals that fight against each other.
Just because Auri-el had Lorkhan killed, and Alkosh fought against Whitestreak when whitestreak killed Khajiit, does not mean Akatosh dislikes Shor/Lorkhan/Sithis
Furthermore Akatosh and Lorkhan/Shor/sithis have teamed up several times, The Dovahkiin, Martin Septim, Tiber Septim, Whitestreak and many other people were avatars of BOTH gods.