Shadows of the Damned was excellent?
Man, I did not see that coming, unless it's a brilliant joke. That game has less content for me to really bite into than a soggy cracker full of air. Could not get into it in the slightest, and quit playing after a few hours when I felt doing laundry would be more fun.
I haven't touched or seen much of Killer is Dead, yet (is it even out yet?), but that doesn't really surprise me. I played Killer 7, and while I love the game, I also remember that I actively hated playing it, and that weird juxtaposition is part of what made me enjoy it. It was twisted, and symbolic, and had almost too much crazy shit going on, and it was amazing as a piece of gaming, but it was also a terrible game, regardless of it's brilliance. It was clunky and jagged and actively felt like an ordeal to play, all while having one of the greatest sets of goings-on in gaming, and being filled with enough off-the-walls, over-the-top outlandishness that fit right in with the zany, madcap antics of the Saints (and their eponymous Row).
Come to think of it, I had much the same issue with No More Heroes, for a time, but then that game actually became fun to play, much like Lollipop Chainsaw. To say a Suda51 game plays fast and loose with making sense, though, that is not hard news to believe. That's like saying ducks have feathers and wear mexican wrestling masks--it's just absolutely easy to find them in conjunction.