But many seem to like it.
I know I know, games these days, and Microsoft, and AAA and whatever, sure sure. But High On Life is doing its own thing- it is a particular brand of humor (and it's not as simply as R&M humor just because it's the same guy... yes, there is similarity in tone, but they're doing different things) and tying that into the gameplay clearly is a goofy kind of fun.
It's like... Evil West, just came out, and some critics ragging on it while to u/Brawlman and myself it's a welcome kind of specific game. HoL is like that, but for a different vibe. I think it's harmless.