The 'test' for psychopaths

Recommended Videos

pffh

New member
Oct 10, 2008
774
0
0
plastic_window said:
pffh said:
Not enough info given. How is her relationship with her sister? Does she have any mental illnesses? and finally how is her life in general, is she poor, what is her job status, if she has no job was she fired recently, if she has a job will she lose it soon for some reason?

etc That's the info we need.
There are four people here, including myself who worked it out without the information you're asking for. But it isn't a straight-forward question anyway - it's one of those ones that psychiatrists (or psychologists, I forget why they're different) use on patients to see what they think beneath the surface. I think the reason why they use it is because it has very little detail. Remember the hospital scene in A Clockwork Orange? Like those speech things that she gives him.

In short, you failed. Try again :p
OR I'm the only sane and reasonable person in here.
 

plastic_window

New member
Jun 29, 2008
1,218
0
0
The_root_of_all_evil said:
There's an obvious problem with this. Psychopaths medically lose the ability to project emotions onto others, which is why they see Jesus instead of Jesus's ghost. So the psychopath's answer would probably be "Why not?"
Perhaps they see the mystery man as a goal. Rather than love, they see attainment. I don't know if that's classified as emotion though, so I may be wrong.
 

Simalacrum

Resident Juggler
Apr 17, 2008
5,204
0
0
irishstormtrooper said:
Because pancakes are delicious?
haha, like this one

as for my answer... erm....

because she found out her sister killed her mother is what popped into my head first... DAMN i have such a boring imagination... :(
 

hannahdonno

New member
Apr 5, 2009
496
0
0
plastic_window said:
Allegedly, this is a test for psycopathic murderers. Yeah, you heard me. More importantly, you saw the word 'allegedly' which means that I don't know if it's true or not.

Besides, this has probably been done before. It's not a very original concept. Anyhoo, here's the question:

A woman goes to her mother's funeral and meets a man there. She dances and romances with him all night, but fails to get his name or number. The next week she kills her sister. Why?
Well, I say: With the loss of her mother the stability she found in family has evapourated, she has lost her female role figure in life. The fact that she does not find out more about this man shows her lack of desire to find an emotional connection with anyone at this traumatic time in her life but a physical connection which she desires. She will probably blame her mother for the emotion she is feeling at this time, and seeing the connection between her mother and sister (older sister maybe, so a strong female role model) causes her to find her as a suitable outlet for the guilt/betrayal she is feeling from the death of her mother.

ANALYSE ME.
 

Uilleand

New member
Mar 20, 2009
387
0
0
plastic_window said:
Allegedly, this is a test for psycopathic murderers. Yeah, you heard me. More importantly, you saw the word 'allegedly' which means that I don't know if it's true or not.

Besides, this has probably been done before. It's not a very original concept. Anyhoo, here's the question:

A woman goes to her mother's funeral and meets a man there. She dances and romances with him all night, but fails to get his name or number. The next week she kills her sister. Why?
I heard this question posed differently the first time I came across it.

It was:
"A woman goes to her mother's funeral and meets a man there. She dances and romances with him all night, but fails to get his name or number. Three weeks later, her sister dies. How did she die?"

The premise being that a sociopath would recognize that the death of a second relative would be the most expedient way for the woman to get what she wants - with zero importance attached to the existence of her sister.
 

Kroker

New member
May 29, 2008
178
0
0
plastic_window said:
Excellent. We can use my house. It's an abandoned abatoir on the lower-east side.

Don't worry about the gangs and whatnot, they know to stay away.

Y'know, even though we know the 'right' answer, it doesn't make me question my mental state. I'm pretty sure that if I was the woman I wouldn't murder my sister. Probably go for the father instead. Hell, he'll probably die in like the next 10 years anyway. Might as well die knowing he gave his daughter a chance to score.
Amen to that. Also, cool I'll bring the booze and bandannas, you bring the chicks and megapenguinx can bring the penguins, I guess. Oh by the way, you don't have any problems with ostriches right? You see, I just had a brilliant idea...
 

Caliostro

Headhunter
Jan 23, 2008
3,253
0
0
plastic_window said:
A woman goes to her mother's funeral and meets a man there. She dances and romances with him all night, but fails to get his name or number. The next week she kills her sister. Why?
So she could meet the man again. Heard it differently before.
 

WilliamWhite1

New member
Sep 27, 2008
277
0
0
I think the answer could vary.

Plenty of people said it could be because she wants to see the man again, but who's to say the man would really show up at the funeral for her sister? The information granted would mean that the man was, perchance, someone very close to the mother who has become very close to her with all of this 'dancing and romancing.' I suppose the sister's death could conjure him, but I would consider a psychopathic killer someone without true reasoning skills of one sort or another.

She could have killed the sister due to an entirely different case.

She could have killed the sister because she also killed the mother and is attempting to relinquish any lasting effects of a possible standing conspiracy against her.

Heck, she could have been thinking of the right way/time to kill the man, and, having failed to do so, killed someone else out of sheer ire.

In a fit of anxiety/panic, she could have killed the sister because of the mother's death.

All of those answers are psychopathic in different ways; anywhere from schizophrenia to personality deficiency disorder to intermittent explosive disorder.
 

plastic_window

New member
Jun 29, 2008
1,218
0
0
pffh said:
OR I'm the only sane and reasonable person in here.
It could be that you're not making up your own facts. Like I said, it's not a straightforward right or wrong answer. Make up what you want about it. The only things that cannot change are the things I've written down, everything else is left up to you.
 

Glerken

New member
Dec 18, 2008
1,539
0
0
hannahdonno said:
plastic_window said:
Allegedly, this is a test for psycopathic murderers. Yeah, you heard me. More importantly, you saw the word 'allegedly' which means that I don't know if it's true or not.

Besides, this has probably been done before. It's not a very original concept. Anyhoo, here's the question:

A woman goes to her mother's funeral and meets a man there. She dances and romances with him all night, but fails to get his name or number. The next week she kills her sister. Why?
Well, I say: With the loss of her mother the stability she found in family has evapourated, she has lost her female role figure in life. The fact that she does not find out more about this man shows her lack of desire to find an emotional connection with anyone at this traumatic time in her life but a physical connection which she desires. She will probably blame her mother for the emotion she is feeling at this time, and seeing the connection between her mother and sister (older sister maybe, so a strong female role model) causes her to find her as a suitable outlet for the guilt/betrayal she is feeling from the death of her mother.

ANALYSE ME.
Makes more sense than the "correct" answer...
 

hannahdonno

New member
Apr 5, 2009
496
0
0
Glerken said:
hannahdonno said:
plastic_window said:
Allegedly, this is a test for psycopathic murderers. Yeah, you heard me. More importantly, you saw the word 'allegedly' which means that I don't know if it's true or not.

Besides, this has probably been done before. It's not a very original concept. Anyhoo, here's the question:

A woman goes to her mother's funeral and meets a man there. She dances and romances with him all night, but fails to get his name or number. The next week she kills her sister. Why?
Well, I say: With the loss of her mother the stability she found in family has evapourated, she has lost her female role figure in life. The fact that she does not find out more about this man shows her lack of desire to find an emotional connection with anyone at this traumatic time in her life but a physical connection which she desires. She will probably blame her mother for the emotion she is feeling at this time, and seeing the connection between her mother and sister (older sister maybe, so a strong female role model) causes her to find her as a suitable outlet for the guilt/betrayal she is feeling from the death of her mother.

ANALYSE ME.
Makes more sense than the "correct" answer...
I think I have just looked far too deeply into it, like I do with most things S;
 

Silver

New member
Jun 17, 2008
1,142
0
0
Kukul said:
megapenguinx said:
She wants to see the man again.
That makes sense, though.
And that's just the point. It's supposed to make sense for people suffering from psycopathic personality disorder. It is, of course, not enough to go on to make such a diagnosis, and is only used for fun.
 

theeconomy

New member
Apr 6, 2009
62
0
0
megapenguinx said:
This is like the other test:
You have a bathtub full of water and you have a spoon, a cup, and a ladle.
Which would you use to get the water out?
The drain.
 

Fuhjem

New member
Jan 17, 2009
267
0
0
Funerals are family events. He was probably a relative. More precisely, her sister's husband. Fueled by psychoic love she wants the man for herself and kills her sister.

It says she "fails to get his name or number". Well maybe that's because she already had them. Or maybe she just learned it later, I don't know.

Ignoring what I just said, I read other peoples comments and saw the one that says,
"She thinks that if there is another funeral, she can see the man again"

It sounds about right.
 

pffh

New member
Oct 10, 2008
774
0
0
Alright I give in. She's obviously a psychopath and that's why she kills her sister I mean who tries to get a date at their mothers funeral. Also in the week that passed she walked in on her sister having a threesome with the man and their mothers corpse.