I actually like Avery Brooks acting style, though it was a rough through the first few seasons. I think he was still adjusting from theater acting to film\television acting. You see similar overblown performances from Patrick Stewart in his early film\television career. In my opinion, Avery Brooks did excellent about 4th season forward. In particular the episode "In the Pale Moonlight" and "For the Uniform" were especially well done.Blablahb said:They always remained handicapped by having chosen such an overblown actor to play Sisko though. He never got rid of the ridiculous exageration when playing emotional angry moments.Crono1973 said:DS9 had it's good episodes prior to season 4, mostly when they were teasing about the Dominion. When DS9 took off in season 4 though, it really took off. Enterprise may have been getting better but it just never hit the high that DS9 did.
I never got far in the Enterprise series. I just couldn't stand how overwhelmingly American everything was, the entire cast and the captain most of all. It was like they took everything that made the various Star Trek series great out, and replaced it with standard hollywood crap. And the cheaper budgets. I mean, Naussicans with leather jackets? One of the greatest parts of Star Trek was being able to watch it without seeing stuff that came straight out of a store, no badguys with motorcycle helmets to dehumanize them and so on. If they used any in the earlier series, I didn't notice it.
As for Enterprise, why do you say it was too American? That doesn't make much sense to me. It was crap, especially for the first 2 seasons, and the crew was white trash, but I can't really say it was any more or less American than the rest of trek.