Squilookle said:
Take a well loved fairytale and make a dark twisted spin on it. That's already so cliched it hurts.
But make a second game... which is just the same crap all over again? There's a word for that.
It's pathetic.
Do they really think we haven't seen the little girl grinning with blood splattered on her face about a thousand times before?
American Mcgee was the first to really bring this trope to fruition. His original game, "American Mcgee's Alice", was not only a well written and intricately designed and stylized game, but paid direct homage to many of Carroll's original (non-disney-fied) characters.
In it, the themes of space and time, insanity, dual personalities, and survivor guilt are examined, while at the same time incorporating the familiar characters in a believable way. They are just as insane, this time taking on a more menacing appearance, but are expertly written in a way that evokes their Wonderland counterparts to a T.
While it has become a VERY tired trope of late, I am nothing but excited for this game: a sequel to the originator, designed by the same Dev as the first.