Brotherofwill said:
What franchises did you think took a wrong turn or were just made stale by bad designing decisions?
Also consider this:
How do you feel about developers trying to adapt other rising genres in their own game to adapt to current conventions?
Any games that pop to your mind that shat all over themselves?
Thing is I played Jak 1 for the plattforming and in that aspect it was brilliant. The changes just ruined it
1: I can name more franchises that went bad than characters in this sentence.
2: It's a terrible idea. They need to understand that what made their game fun and interesting is the exact thing I want to see replicated. I don't want it completely changed (Banjo Kazooie Nuts 'n Bolts) or completely changed with a new theme (Fallout 3 being the best Oblivion mod I ever played. I still enjoyed it a lot, though.)
I hate seeing franchises dumbed down for the masses (Going from System Shock/System Shock 2 to Bioshock is effectively taking a savage, rabid tiger and giving it sedatives until it curls up in your lap and wants to be pet. And that's playing through Bioshock using nothing but the wrench.)
I can understand it gets game sales, but it doesn't leave the customer with a sense of satisfaction. I still really liked Fallout 3, I still really liked Bioshock too. But I'm still going to go back and play Fallout 2 because of things it lets me do that the new one doesn't...
3: I could name a few, but "shat all over themselves" is a bit harsh.
A big one is Master of Orion 3. It was horrifically bad. It took everything I liked about 2 and removed it, and added convoluted bullshit that didn't enhance gameplay at all. It put in a real-time combat system that was clunky and...Ugh. It was as if the designers didn't have anyone actually PLAY the game. Think of it this way: In Master of Orion 2, you could control what colonies build specifically right down to what building. In this one, you're in an arbitrary leader role where you just say "develop this world industrially" and then you have to put a policy into place that takes like a few turns to even start happening, and then you have to deal with corrupt wasteful uses of resources on your planets and..Ugh, it's just so terrible.
Like, I feel "heavily mixed" about Unreal Tournament 3. I liked it, kind of...But I wouldn't really play it? It's the type of thing I can smile and laugh about, but it just makes me want to play other games in the franchise.
Doom 3 was interesting, but a completely different take the series. I enjoyed it to a point, though, but it just wasn't what I wanted from a game that said "Doom" on it. Maybe it's what they wanted to do in the first place.