Twilight: Bella is SUPPOSED to be a flat character.

Doclector

New member
Aug 22, 2009
5,010
0
0
Well, this sort of stuff can sometimes work in games, where a character is given a name, or even the outline of a personality, leaving character and player to merge. It works because gaming is interactive. You can change the actions of the lead character and his/her interactions with other characters.

This, however, does not work so well in books, and definately not in movies. You could argue that books can leave things to the imagination, but the interactions still have to be set, which means as much as you can project yourself onto said protagonist, her actions will still be that of a flat character.

It certainly doesn't work well in movies, where less can be left to the imagination.

In summary, maybe the author was aiming to do it, but it didn't work, and probably would never have worked in the first place.
 

TheRightToArmBears

New member
Dec 13, 2008
8,674
0
0
Yeah, we kinda knew that. That doesn't make it good. For instance, if I intend to fail an exam, and get exactly 0%, my lecturer will still tell me I've failed, rather than praise me for my brilliance.
 

Berithil

Maintenence Man of the Universe
Mar 19, 2009
1,600
0
0
That's pretty much it.

Still doesn't excuse all the other characters.

And doesn't excuse every problem those books have.

But that's a big reason the books are as popular as they are.

And she's still a horrible role model.


Anyways, I thought we were past the whole Twilight thing? Can't we just let it die?

EDIT:

ALRIGHT, WHO NECRO'D THIS THREAD?!

Matt S Hoimyr said:
foul necromancer
[HEADING=3]IT WAS YOU!!! OUT WITH YOU!! YOUR DARK ARTS ARE NOT WELCOME HERE!!!!![/HEADING]

Ahem, anyway. Why resurrect a Twilight thread of all things?
 

Atmos Duality

New member
Mar 3, 2010
8,473
0
0
Bella is written in the classic style of pandering-roleplay.
It's nothing new or original, nor is it a mode of writing that's effective at telling a story.

However, it's suited perfectly for pandering, and it's not all that different in design from any other form of self-insertion fantasy aimed at the teenage male demographic.

How it took off like a rocket, I have no idea, because Meyer's writing abilities are about on par with someone you'd find doing Dracula slash-fics on the net.

ASIDE: The Captcha was something OTHER than spam from DISH or that fucking shingles website?!!
WHAT SORCERY IS THIS??!!
"Dragon with matches"

Damn fucking right I am!