*sigh* read the posts before you.... like, RIGHT before you.TsunamiWombat said:A Pysker and a Jedi would be evenly matched (see Force Unleashed)
psykers/librariens win
*sigh* read the posts before you.... like, RIGHT before you.TsunamiWombat said:A Pysker and a Jedi would be evenly matched (see Force Unleashed)
man i wish there was some hard core SW geeks around here to take up the slack. in the 'extended universe' of Staw wars there are more than just the Empire/Republic factions. if i recall right, the new republic eventualy falls to something much like the tyranids, i know that chewbaca and i thing Anikin gets killed by them, but i cant recall perfectly at the moment and cant be assed to look it up. but basicaly this 'race' of enemys from 'outside the galaxy' invades the SW home galaxy and are made up of more or less bio weapons, they turn planets into bio factorys and shit like that much as i understand the tyranids do. there is also other factions like the Chiss whome produced perhaps the greatest Admiral of all time in science fiction with Grand Admiral Thrawn.Archaeology Hat said:and this is JUST the Imperium of Man, one of the factions of 40k and assuming that the Star Wars Galaxy united against it, bring in Chaos (primal refletions of sentient emotion that take the worst aspects of the Imperium and make them even more horrible) the Tyranids (Omnicidal and Omnivorous swarms that strip planets bare to feed its implied they ate at least one galaxy before coming to the 40k one), Orks (Lunatic 8ft alien monsters who can easily kill a human with their bare hands without trying... and if they expect a bit of technology to work... it will), the Tau (Space Communists with some of the settings most powerful guns), Necrons (Omnicidal Mechanoid serveants of the Star Vampires who never die, terminator style they are capable of re-assembly on and off the battlefield), Craftword Eldar (The Remains of an ancient race who once ruled the galaxy, their goal at the moment is to turn the collective soul-energy of their entire race into a God... to kill the God of Squick they created milennia ago), Dark Eldar (Evil pirate cousins of the Craftworld Eldar who have turned killing and torture into an art for, their jetbikers are so skilled they can cut peoples throats with their bikes.)
Of course what would actually happen is that most of the Star Wars Galaxy would immediatly ally with the Tau (or maybe Eldar... maybe) and the Imperium would end up fighting them along with everyone else in the crazy brawl it is at the moment.
[/nerd]
im not that well versed in 40K space combat lore. i WILL say that in the SW universe what was shown in the movies didnt reflect 'normal' fleet tactics and manuvers. the idea of a Star Destroyer being driven off by a mear Ion cannon, its possable that the ion caoon COULD do just what it did, but a proper fleet commander wouldnt have put his ships in a position to be hit by it in the first place. Ego and underating the rebels were what caused that piss poor example of 'tactics' in ESB. also same with the big battle in ROTJ, according too the books the Emperior was using the force to enhance his fleet crews ability to fight as a single unit, after the Emperors death that enhancment turned into a liability and the fleet which if left to its own devices could have finished crushing the rebel fleet became a "unorganized grabastick piece of shit" (a nickle if you can tell me who taht quotes from)Sergeant M. Fudgey said:You made some very nice points, but the Imperium has the firepower in their fleet. Sure, the Empire is faster, but a Star Destoyer against a Battle Barge and you get Swiss alloy and a content Space Marine crew. I think what the people arguing for WH40K are saying is, whoever has the better guns will do a better job of shooting things, -which is what it will boil down to-. Also, even with the Empire's fleets, the Imperium has some pretty fancy Anti-Spacecraft weaponry; on the ground, which does not bode well for invasions.
one question ....... if the necrons are "absolutely perfect" why havent they beat the Imperium yet?Christemo said:fuck 3po. he can become practice target. oh wait, Necrons have absolutely PERFECT AIM. they can shoot a walnut out of the air a mile away. why? because they are the perfect lifeform.
The Imperium has "sun crusher" technology as well. Well actually not the Imperium, Chaos (Abaddon's flag ship people!) so I think that tech could be ignored (considered anulled). We then move on to psykers - Vader and his Master both make extensive use of tech to deal with their relative lack of command, and their major powers are a force push/punch/choke (Librarian's Storm of the Ancients is probably the closest to this) and force lightning (Librarian has "Storm of the Emperors wrath"). Force sword and light sabre are comparatively equal - each cutting through armour like it is nothing, so ignoring those as well to keep the discussion clean. The difference then is between the strength of the Psykers. A beta class psyker can rip a titan in two on his own. Sweet. Does someone have a comparative strength analysis of the empire? Or of an Alpha level psykers powers. After this strength check, calculate in that the Imperium has Tech to enhance the psychic ability (the boys in blue have something on their main psyker - Tiberius?)guess who said:If we go by the starwars EU then the question becomes "how well can/do they protect their suns?" If we combine the better logicists of starwars with sun crusher technology we get the posibilty of just showing up destroying a star and the nearby planets and moving on before any other systems know what's going on.
Edit: To clarify the people moving on are not the same people crushing the suns.
ReEdit: Never mind I just re-looked it up and it would survive.
True however my arguement was not that the Empire would have better superweapons but rather that unlike say the Imperium have the logistics technology to make the best use of it.Gitsnik said:The Imperium has "sun crusher" technology as well. Well actually not the Imperium, Chaos (Abaddon's flag ship people!) so I think that tech could be ignored (considered anulled). We then move on to psykers - Vader and his Master both make extensive use of tech to deal with their relative lack of command, and their major powers are a force push/punch/choke (Librarian's Storm of the Ancients is probably the closest to this) and force lightning (Librarian has "Storm of the Emperors wrath"). Force sword and light sabre are comparatively equal - each cutting through armour like it is nothing, so ignoring those as well to keep the discussion clean. The difference then is between the strength of the Psykers. A beta class psyker can rip a titan in two on his own. Sweet. Does someone have a comparative strength analysis of the empire? Or of an Alpha level psykers powers. After this strength check, calculate in that the Imperium has Tech to enhance the psychic ability (the boys in blue have something on their main psyker - Tiberius?)guess who said:If we go by the starwars EU then the question becomes "how well can/do they protect their suns?" If we combine the better logicists of starwars with sun crusher technology we get the posibilty of just showing up destroying a star and the nearby planets and moving on before any other systems know what's going on.
Edit: To clarify the people moving on are not the same people crushing the suns.
ReEdit: Never mind I just re-looked it up and it would survive.
The Emperial technology that strips planets (for harvesting) - the name of which escapes me but I believe it was used on Akbars home planet - is comparative to the Imperial Cyclonic Torpedos (again with the name) being used for Exterminatus on a planet.
And then there is the (Imperial) Emperor, able to project his psychic force across half the galaxy. The 4 chaos "gods" and the Eldar. Also the anti-psyker imperial assassins.
I'll let someone else do the math hammer on physical weaponry, but the big guns are mutual, and psykers seem to be stronger in 40k.
Necrons have motherships that eat suns. That's pretty tough to beat. The sheer strength of the WH40K factions would win it for them, sure, SW has more than what was in the movies, but how much of it is stronger than what was in the movies? Not a whole lot. The SW Golem stations sound fairly strong, but they don't move, Dark Eldar ships could dance circles around them, destroy them, and pillage the planet before anyone knew what happened. Honestly, if they have such great technology, isn't that all the more reason for everyone to want to take it? If the Orks got involved, then you would have meteors full of Orks crashing into SW ships and SW planets. WH40K has the best firepower around, face it.Wyatt said:man i wish there was some hard core SW geeks around here to take up the slack. in the 'extended universe' of Staw wars there are more than just the Empire/Republic factions. if i recall right, the new republic eventualy falls to something much like the tyranids, i know that chewbaca and i thing Anikin gets killed by them, but i cant recall perfectly at the moment and cant be assed to look it up. but basicaly this 'race' of enemys from 'outside the galaxy' invades the SW home galaxy and are made up of more or less bio weapons, they turn planets into bio factorys and shit like that much as i understand the tyranids do. there is also other factions like the Chiss whome produced perhaps the greatest Admiral of all time in science fiction with Grand Admiral Thrawn.Archaeology Hat said:and this is JUST the Imperium of Man, one of the factions of 40k and assuming that the Star Wars Galaxy united against it, bring in Chaos (primal refletions of sentient emotion that take the worst aspects of the Imperium and make them even more horrible) the Tyranids (Omnicidal and Omnivorous swarms that strip planets bare to feed its implied they ate at least one galaxy before coming to the 40k one), Orks (Lunatic 8ft alien monsters who can easily kill a human with their bare hands without trying... and if they expect a bit of technology to work... it will), the Tau (Space Communists with some of the settings most powerful guns), Necrons (Omnicidal Mechanoid serveants of the Star Vampires who never die, terminator style they are capable of re-assembly on and off the battlefield), Craftword Eldar (The Remains of an ancient race who once ruled the galaxy, their goal at the moment is to turn the collective soul-energy of their entire race into a God... to kill the God of Squick they created milennia ago), Dark Eldar (Evil pirate cousins of the Craftworld Eldar who have turned killing and torture into an art for, their jetbikers are so skilled they can cut peoples throats with their bikes.)
Of course what would actually happen is that most of the Star Wars Galaxy would immediatly ally with the Tau (or maybe Eldar... maybe) and the Imperium would end up fighting them along with everyone else in the crazy brawl it is at the moment.
[/nerd]
as i say i wish more SW geeks that knew more details of the 'extended universe' were around there is ALOT more to star wars than just the 6 movies.
im not that well versed in 40K space combat lore. i WILL say that in the SW universe what was shown in the movies didnt reflect 'normal' fleet tactics and manuvers. the idea of a Star Destroyer being driven off by a mear Ion cannon, its possable that the ion caoon COULD do just what it did, but a proper fleet commander wouldnt have put his ships in a position to be hit by it in the first place. Ego and underating the rebels were what caused that piss poor example of 'tactics' in ESB. also same with the big battle in ROTJ, according too the books the Emperior was using the force to enhance his fleet crews ability to fight as a single unit, after the Emperors death that enhancment turned into a liability and the fleet which if left to its own devices could have finished crushing the rebel fleet became a "unorganized grabastick piece of shit" (a nickle if you can tell me who taht quotes from)Sergeant M. Fudgey said:You made some very nice points, but the Imperium has the firepower in their fleet. Sure, the Empire is faster, but a Star Destoyer against a Battle Barge and you get Swiss alloy and a content Space Marine crew. I think what the people arguing for WH40K are saying is, whoever has the better guns will do a better job of shooting things, -which is what it will boil down to-. Also, even with the Empire's fleets, the Imperium has some pretty fancy Anti-Spacecraft weaponry; on the ground, which does not bode well for invasions.
furthermore you dont get too see the actual TRUE size of the Empires fleet. the entire fleet in ROTJ was just one sectors fleet, and there are literaly hundereds of sectors in the galaxy, plus there is all kinds of support units, Such as golom battle stations which are basicaly death stars without the super laser that are used for fixed planet defence, add in the planetary shields, the fixed fortifications and the size and power of the fleet and i think you would find that the 40K badasses would still hands down have an edge in a ground combat but i dont think it would be a walk in the park for any space combat.
the better speed, more freedom of movment and generaly atleast as powerful ships would give the Empire a real edge.
one question ....... if the necrons are "absolutely perfect" why havent they beat the Imperium yet?Christemo said:fuck 3po. he can become practice target. oh wait, Necrons have absolutely PERFECT AIM. they can shoot a walnut out of the air a mile away. why? because they are the perfect lifeform.
seems to me that just one "absolutely perfect" necron should be able to destroy anything put up against it and given a whole army of them, well now...... just load up a troop ship, drop off one per planet and thats it, game over right?
silly boy.
Super Jedi harnesses the Force into a single blast of super Hadouken that destroys the whole goddamn universe.Zeke the Freak said:This isnt a VS thread, I know 40k is over the top, i was just wondering if there was a loop hole that enabled the SW universe to even have a chance.
lightsabers can chop throw chainsaw swords. lightsabers can chop through anyhitng.Wouldukindly said:Death stars? They regularly dust planets with doomsday devices (notice the plural).CountFenring said:I'm not sure but I don't think 40k has an equivalent of the Death Star or LightSabers. Correct me if I'm wrong.
LightSabers? Chainsaws or power gear that can chop through Terminator armour.
because 3/4 of all necrons are asleep in the underground of alot of planets across the universe. no, necron squads cant beat a whole Empire. but what u dont think about is that the Necrons are ENDLESS. Why? ill explain.Wyatt said:man i wish there was some hard core SW geeks around here to take up the slack. in the 'extended universe' of Staw wars there are more than just the Empire/Republic factions. if i recall right, the new republic eventualy falls to something much like the tyranids, i know that chewbaca and i thing Anikin gets killed by them, but i cant recall perfectly at the moment and cant be assed to look it up. but basicaly this 'race' of enemys from 'outside the galaxy' invades the SW home galaxy and are made up of more or less bio weapons, they turn planets into bio factorys and shit like that much as i understand the tyranids do. there is also other factions like the Chiss whome produced perhaps the greatest Admiral of all time in science fiction with Grand Admiral Thrawn.Archaeology Hat said:and this is JUST the Imperium of Man, one of the factions of 40k and assuming that the Star Wars Galaxy united against it, bring in Chaos (primal refletions of sentient emotion that take the worst aspects of the Imperium and make them even more horrible) the Tyranids (Omnicidal and Omnivorous swarms that strip planets bare to feed its implied they ate at least one galaxy before coming to the 40k one), Orks (Lunatic 8ft alien monsters who can easily kill a human with their bare hands without trying... and if they expect a bit of technology to work... it will), the Tau (Space Communists with some of the settings most powerful guns), Necrons (Omnicidal Mechanoid serveants of the Star Vampires who never die, terminator style they are capable of re-assembly on and off the battlefield), Craftword Eldar (The Remains of an ancient race who once ruled the galaxy, their goal at the moment is to turn the collective soul-energy of their entire race into a God... to kill the God of Squick they created milennia ago), Dark Eldar (Evil pirate cousins of the Craftworld Eldar who have turned killing and torture into an art for, their jetbikers are so skilled they can cut peoples throats with their bikes.)
Of course what would actually happen is that most of the Star Wars Galaxy would immediatly ally with the Tau (or maybe Eldar... maybe) and the Imperium would end up fighting them along with everyone else in the crazy brawl it is at the moment.
[/nerd]
as i say i wish more SW geeks that knew more details of the 'extended universe' were around there is ALOT more to star wars than just the 6 movies.
im not that well versed in 40K space combat lore. i WILL say that in the SW universe what was shown in the movies didnt reflect 'normal' fleet tactics and manuvers. the idea of a Star Destroyer being driven off by a mear Ion cannon, its possable that the ion caoon COULD do just what it did, but a proper fleet commander wouldnt have put his ships in a position to be hit by it in the first place. Ego and underating the rebels were what caused that piss poor example of 'tactics' in ESB. also same with the big battle in ROTJ, according too the books the Emperior was using the force to enhance his fleet crews ability to fight as a single unit, after the Emperors death that enhancment turned into a liability and the fleet which if left to its own devices could have finished crushing the rebel fleet became a "unorganized grabastick piece of shit" (a nickle if you can tell me who taht quotes from)Sergeant M. Fudgey said:You made some very nice points, but the Imperium has the firepower in their fleet. Sure, the Empire is faster, but a Star Destoyer against a Battle Barge and you get Swiss alloy and a content Space Marine crew. I think what the people arguing for WH40K are saying is, whoever has the better guns will do a better job of shooting things, -which is what it will boil down to-. Also, even with the Empire's fleets, the Imperium has some pretty fancy Anti-Spacecraft weaponry; on the ground, which does not bode well for invasions.
furthermore you dont get too see the actual TRUE size of the Empires fleet. the entire fleet in ROTJ was just one sectors fleet, and there are literaly hundereds of sectors in the galaxy, plus there is all kinds of support units, Such as golom battle stations which are basicaly death stars without the super laser that are used for fixed planet defence, add in the planetary shields, the fixed fortifications and the size and power of the fleet and i think you would find that the 40K badasses would still hands down have an edge in a ground combat but i dont think it would be a walk in the park for any space combat.
the better speed, more freedom of movment and generaly atleast as powerful ships would give the Empire a real edge.
one question ....... if the necrons are "absolutely perfect" why havent they beat the Imperium yet?Christemo said:fuck 3po. he can become practice target. oh wait, Necrons have absolutely PERFECT AIM. they can shoot a walnut out of the air a mile away. why? because they are the perfect lifeform.
seems to me that just one "absolutely perfect" necron should be able to destroy anything put up against it and given a whole army of them, well now...... just load up a troop ship, drop off one per planet and thats it, game over right?
silly boy.
if 1 of IGs lasguns cant hurt power armor, lightys cant either. Power Armor is so freaking hard, and the marine in under is unbelieveably tough, u could´nt kill him with a cruise missile. and the SM bolter is using 75-caliber bullets. real-life 50-caliber bullets can blow the head of a man if u shoot him in the jaw. 75-caliber bullets are capable of blasting the foot off a soldier if u shoot him just under the knee.42manZ said:lightsabers can chop throw chainsaw swords. lightsabers can chop through anyhitng.Wouldukindly said:Death stars? They regularly dust planets with doomsday devices (notice the plural).CountFenring said:I'm not sure but I don't think 40k has an equivalent of the Death Star or LightSabers. Correct me if I'm wrong.
LightSabers? Chainsaws or power gear that can chop through Terminator armour.
Except croitoss weave, but we all know that was a EU retcon so that the use of swords could make more sense.
oh yes, and both death stars was destroyed by a traumatized Teen. Necron motherships wouldnt search for a weak spot, they would swiss-cheese it and say "screw the rest, those monkeys is already doomed.42manZ said:lightsabers can chop throw chainsaw swords. lightsabers can chop through anyhitng.Wouldukindly said:Death stars? They regularly dust planets with doomsday devices (notice the plural).CountFenring said:I'm not sure but I don't think 40k has an equivalent of the Death Star or LightSabers. Correct me if I'm wrong.
LightSabers? Chainsaws or power gear that can chop through Terminator armour.
Except croitoss weave, but we all know that was a EU retcon so that the use of swords could make more sense.
They wouldn't have to with adequate shields.Gormourn said:Do any droids magically resurrect on the battlefields?Bob_Bobbington said:On the subject of droids do any Necrons have personal shields?