Samtemdo8 said:
And the look and athmopshere of Shadow of the Colossus would definately be even more better if it was remade from the ground up for PS4 standards (Think games like Bloodborne and the Upcoming Dark Souls 3)
So what do you think deserves the better graphics treatment?
I'm one of those people (assuming there are others who think this) who actually preferred the Ps2 version of SotC to the Ps3, HD rerelease. Although, this isn't so much that I disliked the idea of an HD version, but that the HD version was horribly made. The main issue was the lighting. The bloom would go from extreme to nothing just by moving a step or two. They also kind of hampered the gameplay, but that isn't a graphics issue.
This is a hard question though, I'm trying to think of games where the graphics impaired an otherwise enjoyable experience. Vampire The Masquerade: Bloodlines was a little weak in the visuals department (coming from someone who played it a decade after it came out), I think a lot could be added to it if those were a little better.
Ico might be another one, although I'd trade HD graphics for a proper third person camera