That's a rough comparison. The Casey and his bully are not in a shared restroom wrapped in towels, not a single one of them ends up naked and/or dead as a result of their fight and they are not in space learning to be raid canisters in human form.Paksenarrion said:Ender's Game, anyone?
I'm going to quote a snippet from the latest Penny Arcade post:chunkeymonke said:Most have you have probaly heard / read the story of Casey the kid who got bullied and pile drove the bully into a sidewalk. There is a thread about it on this site, but on that thread and throughout the entire internet people are congratulating Casey
Casey nearly killed another child in a fit of rage, this is not a good thing! The bully wasnt right at all and should be punished but what about Casey? What is next time he goes into a rage fit he pile drives or pushes a kid and accidently kills them like he almost did already?
It's possible he can accidently dump the kid into radioactive waste and turn him into Spiderman.chunkeymonke said:What is next time he goes into a rage fit he pile drives or pushes a kid and accidently kills them like he almost did already?
I feel I'm different. I'd never condone causing another person/self-aware creature pain without any greater and balancing purpose (revenge doesn't count). So if, for example, this had been an isolated incident and Casey had flown off the handle, I'd be against it (though, given the situation, violence would have been the only productive solution, so if it had been an isolated incident, I wouldn't have been opposed to punching the bully in the gut and pinning him to the ground in a non-lethal manner). However, this was a chain of bullying with Casey suffering actualy physical damage from it (not to mention the emotional/psychological abuse) so therefore I completely condone this (I'd have preferred it to be a less risky method, you know, one that doesn't have such a close-call with death, but I still condone it because it is the best course of action to stop the bully).AmrasCalmacil said:Still, some people, such as myself, have a sense of justice in which violent acts that are wrong are rewarded with greater violence in order to place the perpetrator in the victims place, and let them suffer it a little.
That might be why they're cheering him on.
Exactly. What Casey did not only showed amazing self-restraint (three face-punches before a reaction, and then one single move which served to stop the bully). I mean seriously, at least a year of bullying, physcially and emotionally, and his retaliation is not only in self-defence, and not only considerably reasonable (given that we can probably all agree that a physically dominant response is the only one that would have had actualy results), but also well-restrained. Sure, a pile-driver may seems like a non-restrained gesture, but picking someone up and throwing them tends more towards the 'non-lethal/control' intent rather than the vengeance driven ''beat them in the face with your fists' tactic. The fact that it could have easily killed the boy seems more like an accident of the situation, rather than any intent to risk the bully's life.Swollen Goat said:Dude, I wouldn't worry about Casey flying into a rage. It took three solid blows to the face before he reacted. And even then, he stopped immediately after the slam instead of continuing to attack.
Yep, natural selection.Frankydee said:Then they shouldn't be bullying him in the first place.
Also natural selection.
The "three strikes and your out rule", My dad taught me that one.BanthaFodder said:if the kid got hurt, it's his own damn fault. I wonder what's wrong with the people who think Casey would have been better off allowing the little shit to kick his ass. it's sick. Casey did the right thing. every kid should take this as an example to follow: if a kid puts their hands on you, give em 3 chances to stop. if they don't stop coming at you, kick their ass until they stop. incapacitate, nothing more.
Just, wow. Calm down. Exaggerations like that are totally unnecessary to make this point.chunkeymonke said:Casey nearly killed another child in a fit of rage
sorry this has nothing to do with the thread but...is that Legion in a dress? LOL <3 it!Weskerbot3000 said:Si cis pacem, para bellum
If you want peace, prepare for war
There are some people who can't respond to reason, so in the end Casey was in the right.
Well to be fair, deities are just bullies with supernatural powers. That's part of the reason I wrecked up their system.Daystar Clarion said:That comment, paired with your avatar.Souplex said:You can't bully if you're too broken to move.
You my good man, are priceless.
"You can't be a deity if you're too broken to move!"
Wrong fight. The first one, before he went to space.w@rew0lf said:That's a rough comparison. The Casey and his bully are not in a shared restroom wrapped in towels, not a single one of them ends up naked and/or dead as a result of their fight and they are not in space learning to be raid canisters in human form.Paksenarrion said:Ender's Game, anyone?
Because kids IRL are even worse than kids on the internet. At least someone will call you retarded with abandon on the internet without any qualms, which does help keep the entirety of the internet from being a total bloodbath.PhunkyPhazon said:I wasn't aware this kid was almost killed. But fact of the matter is, he had bullying this guy for some time and was literally punching the kid. I see this as self defense, clearly.
BTW, why the hell was someone videotaping this incident to begin with?