I would have to say... Bully. Definitely Bully. That game kicked all sorts of butt, and ranks right up there as one of my favorite PS2 games of all time. Max Payne 1+2 come close, but not close enough.
Damn, another great non sandbox game by Rockstar. Good you mention it.Gorilla Gunk said:No love for Manhunt? For shame. That game has more social subtext than L.A. Noire.