I've got two games I finished at about the same time.
One was Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword. It's good points were that it had some really fun puzzles, innovative controls for puzzle-solving and platforming, all of the sections in the Silent Realm, and Impa and Groose (don't look at me like that; I thought he had some decent character development throughout, and he was way more interesting than Zelda was). On the downside, it had shitty combat controls, items that were were STAGGERINGLY underwhelming (I'm looking at you, whip and gallow's bellow), and Fi. Overall, I'd gave it about a 7/10.
I also played Sword & Sworcery for the iPhone, the only game that has EVER told me to go and do something else for two weeks. I was really impressed by the music and atmosphere of the game, the surreal boss fight and puzzle sections, the story, the art design, and the overall uniqueness of the experience. I wasn't so hot about the support characters and the character design in general, but it wasn't so much that they were bad as that they were somewhat underwhelming compared to how great everything else in the game was. My score for it is 9.5/10. Seriously. Pick this up NOW, it's only like $5.