I think I've run into you on this before... Anyway.The Wykydtron said:Oh what? They changed the menu for Golden as well? I tell you, everything I hear about this so called "best" version is hardly persuading me to get a Vita to play it. Next you'll tell me there's a new super bad ending where the main character betrays everyone to cover up the killer's crimes, completely breaking the entire theme of the game for no reason. But really, what possible reason could they have to even think of putting that into the game?BM19 said:Agreed; honestly, the menu screen I think is the only advantage the original PS2 version has over Golden. Same for the title video, though P4G's grew on me.The Wykydtron said:Definitely Persona 4. It's all yellow and cool and shit. I have no idea how they thought it up but bright (but not too bright) yellow is the main aesthetic of the game. It's totally awesome.
I mean it's brilliant in several other sorts of ways as well (like how all the characters are silhouettes in the background, I think they aren't even there depending on how far you are into the game and you have to REALLY squint to get a glimpse of Naoto)
Oh and that's the second screen. The first screen is the Swagtagonist being swaggy running in slow motion on the left and a giant P4 on the right.
Ocarina of Time has a good one; Majora's Mask has a really minimalist/creepy and tone-setting one as well.
... In fact, all of the 3D Zelda's have pretty sweet intro/menu screens.
Oh wait...
I like the optional ending. It works with the idea of the Fool, an arcanum marked by potential, which can be for good or for bad. It in no way goes against the theme of the game, instead playing on the theme of the silent protagonist and making him more of a social manipulator than what amounts to everyone's therapist. And again, it's OPTIONAL. If your version of the main character wouldn't do it, then nothing has changed. It's just there for those who are curious, and its certainly interesting.
And the new menu screen isn't bad -- it just isn't as iconically good. The music is still great, the visuals are fleshed out (on the Vita, at least; screenshots seem to look terrible, though the widescreen bump is much appreciated) and the extras (music videos, promos, video/music/concept art gallery, in-depth "lessons" on the arcanum and their place in the game/mythology, etc.) are a lot of fun.
It's definitely the best version, IMO. Perhaps not worth buying a Vita for (because that's INSANE), but a must-buy if you do have one.
Also, on-topic, Persona 4 Arena's changing menu screen is worth an honorable mention.