I simply do not understand.Red X said:Anyway I find FatM singing abrasive and damn near irritating as "mezzo"-sopranos go i wish half the time she would keep an octave but she goes up an down like no ones business the only good thing i can say about that is at least she's not boring to listen to. Also because she sings with her voice -lets say- up and down me personally i find it hard to gauge a single emotion i won't call it "schizophrenic" but it's off putting
Yes, she multi-octaves... but she's allowed to, because she actually can. And she doesn't go up-and-down-and-up-and-down, she goes up as the song builds and down as it pulls back. It's called "structure".
<youtube=V_eOmvM-4zc>
There, she's depressed.
Or this?
<youtube=WbN0nX61rIs>
Here, she's defiantly optimistic.
And this?
<youtube=NnIzbukJOHQ>
Here, she's regretful.
Etc, etc.
I'm not saying your opinion is invalid - I'm sure you don't like Florence - but I've never gotten a really valid reason why from anybody beyond "she sings within her abilities" or silly exaggeration. That's not a good reason.