I'm usually all for "the man" coming down hard on criminals and cheaters and hackers and such, but this just isn't fair. I agree that this isn't cheating, he shouldn't be banned for it. Sure he should have reported it when he got it, but it seems he's one WoW player among many who has managed to realize one thing: It's just a game. As he said, it's just for fun. So what if he got an item that let him slaughter all his enemies? Take it away, maybe suspend his account for some time, and leave it at that. Blizzard's the one that gave it to him after all. They're taking this way too seriously.