I have quite a few of these to get off my chest.
First off I preordered Duke Nukem Forever and loved it. It's not going to win any awards and YES it's filled with cliches. But if you turn your brain off it's fun. Though whoever designed that underwater stage near the end needs to be fired.
I LOVE the Dynasty Warriors games and have been playing number 7 to death most of the summer.
I consider Dragon Age 2 to be VASTLY superior to Origins. Funner combat, more distinctive art design (origins looked too much like oblivion in my opinion), a plot that (while a bit less epic) was much more focused with better character development, and of course a main character who can actually SPEAK and thus have a personality. Yes I wish that environments were repeated less but it added to the feeling that you were actually affecting the city.
I have no love whatsoever for the Halo series, for one simple reason, Master Chief, He has zero personality, barely speaks, when he does speak it's only to spout generic action movie lines, and to top it off despite being a so-called super-soldier he never really seems to do much in gameplay that couldn't have been done by someone else. I've only ever finished number 2 and that was because of the Arbiter (Wish I could have played the whole game as him, much more interesting character).
I simply don't get why people get so addicted to WoW. I've played it (to around lvl 35) and frankly, while I don't HATE it, i just got bored out of my skull.
I COMPLETELY agree with Yahtzee's idea that a game should be able to stand on the strength of it's single player campaign. Nothing kills my interest in a game faster than knowing that the multiplayer was the focus. Even worse is when there's no singleplayer at all (I know at least one of the Tom Clancy games was like this, as well as several smaller titles on xbla). Borderlands is the exception because while it's meant for multiplayer it can be played just fine single.
I hate FF7 and everything about it. Clouds a whiny little emo kid, sephiroth is a mama's boy(not just an insult, think about it for a second), a Aeris (yes I called her the original American name Aerith is an even dumber name) was a useless character in gameplay. In the story they may have needed her to get the white materia but nothing she could do in gameplay really felt like it couldn't be done just as well by anyone else.
sorry for the wall of text. lol