Your Rarest Game

[Fightgarr]

Monster Rancher 2 - The best in the series, its very hard to find.
Grim Fandango - The first disc is messed up but I still own a legit copy.
Earthworm Jim 3D - Had to go to Holland to find it.
System Shock 2 - I found a copy this past summer and snatched it up.
Ico - Had to search a long ass time to find this one and it was expensive shit.

These aren't all that rare but bear in mind that I didn't use the internet to find any of them.

 

[Lord_Ascendant]

Civilization

the first one ever made

and the first Ultima ever made

 

[irrelevantnugget]

American Mcgees Alice, it was so hard to get a hold of, but so worth it.

I stumbled upon it at a flea market. Cha-ching. Bought it together with Oni, which is also pretty rare, I think.
Also, I think I'm one of the few people who still have a working copy of Theme Hospital (though it's badly scratched)

 

[destroyer383]

ive never seen another copy of metalfetige and total anilation

 

[CorDemian]

E.T. for the Atari.

 

[Snotnarok]

They're not all super rare but here:

PSOne
Xenogears
Breath of Fire 3 & 4

Genesis:
Phantasy Star IV

Saturn:
Guardian Heroes
Legend of Oasis

 

[Otterpoet]

ICO (if you live in North America, you'll know this game is a real ***** to find)

No kidding. Ever 'Best Of PS2' article I've read lists ICO as a must have. I looked for it and looked for it, only it find a copy hidden in the back of a used game store.

 

[RheynbowDash]

If anyone's interested, I'm willing to part with my copy of Stretch Panic for the PS2.

[link]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stretch_Panic[/link]

Its in its original box, instruction manual, and no scratches on the CD.

Drop me a message if ur interested.

 

[Mister Benoit]

The lowest I've seen a boxed copy of Earthbound go for in the past couple months was 230US and that won't happen anymore, usually goes for around 290$US. I've lost many auctions ugh.. Really want a copy.

Also for anyone saying Ico, just check ebay you can pick it up for like 40$ Possibly less.

 

[Isalan]

Parappa the Rapper on the PS1. Weird game but you just don't see it around anymore.

 

[cyrad]

Final Fantasy III (also known as FFVI) for the SNES. I traded an even rarer game, FFII, for it a long time ago. I ended up finding the FFII at a pawn shop for 20 bucks and then after I beat it, I traded it in for 35 bucks to get Final Fantasy III. I regret not keeping it and just finding some other way to get the money, but I do love FFIII a heck a lot.

The Final Fantasy II would have probably been worth a lot now. It came with the box and instruction booklet. However, I lost the box and an idiot neighbor kid ripped my Stretch-arm Strong and spilled its goo all over the manual. The goo caused the manual to harden like a rock with all its pages stuck together.

 

[Otterpoet]

System Shock 2 (one of the best games I've ever played)

 

[Mister Benoit]

I used to own Shaq Fu on the Genesis. [ashamed]

Also I'm the proud owner of Sparkster II!!! One of the best games on the Genesis.

I recently bought a factory sealed copy of Shaq Fu for Snes for 2$ heh. Also have Sparkster for the Snes.

 

[Maileigh]

I own a copies of Suikoden 1 and 2 for the Playstation.
You can't find those games in any store (at least not around here) anymore.

 

[Nulfinator]

Marvel vs Capcom 2 on the xbox

 

[afterburnzz]

Bunch of PS1 games, like Tony Hawk's Pro Skater , Spyro the Dragon, The Emperor's New Groove and a lot of others, like Dinosaur... As for PC...daamn...Caesar 2? Frogger:the Great Quest?
Will Rock?

 

[OuroborosChoked]

ICO (if you live in North America, you'll know this game is a real ***** to find)

I found it in Wal Mart in 2005, brand new, for $15.

I think they did a second pressing of it around that time...

 

[Uncle Colin]

Freedom fighters?? I have never seen a copy of that in a shop and only came across mine by accident

Really, I have that and I didn't think it was very rare.


I wonder if anyone still has a copy of Superman 64, or have all of those been destroyed.

 

[Danny3005]

FFVII is hardly rare, there are far to many fanboys,... and i saw it at gamestop for 3 bucks...

 

[The_Deleted]

Rule of Rose. Found a copy in some rough ass second hand shop. Never released in the UK.
Guitaroo Man. PS2. Tried it today after owning it for months and it's stupid hard...
War of The Monsters PS2
Dreamfall XBOX
SOS: The Fianl Escape PS2