Your top 5?

[Normalgamer]

I know, I know this thread has been done before, but only part of it!


It's a simple thread, what are you top 5(Of all time) of my wonderful categories:
Best multiplayer
Best most "Everything I just did in the game was pointless story-wise"
Best game of 2000-2009
Top 5 RPG
Most heart-breaking game
Best FPS
Most penguin-esque game
Most immersive/Best story
Most realistic(Sims don't count)
Worst 5 games overall
Top 5 games overall

If this is too daunting, I'll make it shorter:
Most realistic
Worst 5 games
Top 5 games




Note: If five is too much for you limit it to one and call it good if need be.
Me personally?
Best multiplayer:
1.League of legends
Best "everything I just did in that game was pointless"
1. Prototype

Best game of 2000-2009
1.Tales of symphonia


Top RPG:
Paper mario
Most heart-breaking game:
1.Pikmin 1&2

Top FPS:
1.No.
Most pengiun-esque:
1.Attack of the killer penguins are cloud nine. Or animal crossing.

Top immersive
1.Mass effect series
Most realistic game(Besides Sims)
The ship


Top 5 worst games overall
1.Final fantasy 7(Because it spawned the thing we now know as "Fanboys", and made every JRPG follow suit in design.)
2.Rayman raving rabbids
3. ET for the atari
4.Leisure suit larry
5. Leisure suit larry 2

Top 5 best games overall
1.Tales of symphonia
2.Paper mario 1&2
3.Mass effect 1&2
4.Oblivion
5.Kirby 64

So escapists, what do you think of my choices? And how do yours differ?

 

[run_forrest_run]

What the bloody hell?????

This ain't as simple as you think it is. There's far too much to do here. You should just stick to one of these.

 

[AvsJoe]

Best multiplayer

I'm sure I clocked over 1000 hours playing against or with friends in NFL 2004. Maybe not the best but it provided the most memories.

Best most "Everything I just did in the game was pointless story-wise"

Culdecept Saga. No game provides a better example of Yahtzee's chain link fence made of tigers than this game.

Best game of 2000-2009

Legend of Disgaea: Hour of Darkness

Top 5 RPG

FFVII, FFT, Vandal Hearts 2, Legend of Disgaea: Hour of Darkness, FFIX

Most heart-breaking game

FFVII

Best FPS

Counter-Strike

Most penguin-esque game

Legend of Disgaea: Hour of Darkness, dood.

Most immersive/Best story

FFVII

Most realistic(Sims don't count)

Every Day the Same Dream

Worst 5 games overall

Colosseum: Road to Freedom, Culdecept Saga... I got nothing else; I only play good games.

Top 5 games overall

FFVII, FFT, Vandal Hearts 2, Legend of Disgaea: Hour of Darkness, NHL 2000.

 

[AMMO Kid]

I like all most all the games I own - I'm sure they all fit into all those options

 

[Judgement101]

Im confused

 

[Normalgamer]

What the bloody hell?????

This ain't as simple as you think it is. There's far too much to do here. You should just stick to one of these.

Play the amnesiac game with me, when I say "Best game ever" what comes to your mind? Do it with all of them.

 

[Anticitizen_Two]

0___0

...I... this is confusing me...

 

[Tourette]

Paper,scissors,stone > all

 

[Ilikemilkshake]

Best multiplayer
i'd say battlefield 2 or guild wars, soooo much time spent playing both of those

Best most "Everything I just did in the game was pointless story-wise"
i'd agree on prototype, i pretty much completed the game 100% and i still had almost no clue what was going on

Best game of 2000-2009
tooo many =[

Top 5 RPG
mass effect 1+2, oblivion, fable, fallout 3 and dragon age

Most heart-breaking game
i cant think of any at the moment but i know there have been a few that ive been gutted about where someone dies or something
oh infact ihave one but im not sure how to do spoiler tags so i'll leave it for now

Best FPS
battlefield 2

Most penguin-esque game
uhhh

Most immersive/Best story
probably any of my top 5 rpg's

Most realistic(Sims don't count)
battlefield 2 with project reality is pretty realistic

Worst 5 games overall
lots of games... especially film tie ins

Top 5 games overall
probably any of the rpgs i've said

 

[McNinja]

I'll do my top five, as the rest would take too much thinking, and I don't have a top 5 worst games, because I spend my money wisely.

5. Mass Effect 2
4. Mass Effect
3. Ninja Gaiden Black
2. Fable
1. Zone of the Enders: The Second Runner

 

[Good morning blues]

Know what? Let's do it. Based purely on games I've played.

Best multiplayer:
1) Quake (the original)
2) Red Orchestra
3) Call of Duty
4) Battlefield 2142
5) HL2DM

Best most "Everything I just did in the game was pointless story-wise":
1) Half-Life (Let's face it ? there were a grand total of 5 important plot points in this game with 3 concentrated at the end. I still love it.)
2) Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas (Similar thing ? lots of story, but very little time spent on the main plot.)
3) Chronicles of Riddick: Escape From Butcher Bay
4) Oblivion
5) Beneath a Steel Sky

Best game of 2000-2009:
1) Half-Life 2: Episode Two
2) Half-Life 2
3) Call of Duty: Modern Warfare
4) The Witcher
5) Knights of the Old Republic

Top 5 RPG:
1) Quest for Glory: So You Want To Be A Hero?
2) Final Fantasy VII
3) The Witcher
4) Knights of the Old Republic
5) Mass Effect

Most heart-breaking game:
1) Enter the Matrix (I paid $60 for this shit?!?)
2) Final Fantasy VII
3) Fallout 3 (If you take the time to notice it)
4) Half-Life 2 (Again, if you take the time to notice it)
5) Planescape: Torment

Best FPS:
1) Half-Life 2: Episode 2
2) Half-Life 2
3) Call of Duty: Modern Warfare
4) Call of Duty
5) Far Cry

Most penguin-esque game:
1) Trilby's Notes
2) Hitman 2
3) Final Fantasy VII
4) Return to Castle Wolfenstein
5) No One Lives Forever

Most immersive/Best story:
1) Half-Life 2 + episodes
2) Knights of the Old Republic
3) Metal Gear Solid
4) Final Fantasy VII
5) The Witcher

Most realistic(Sims don't count):
1) Red Orchestra
2) Ghost Recon
3) STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl
4) Far Cry
5) Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory

Worst 5 games overall:
1) Flux World
2) Animorphs
3) Smokin' Weed
4) Enter the Matrix
5) Red Faction

Top 5 games overall:
1) Half-Life 2 + episodes
2) Quest for Glory: So You Want to Be a Hero?
3) Final Fantasy VII
4) Space Quest III
5) Call of Duty: Modern Warfare

 

[Ironic Pirate]

Okay, but only three. 'Cuz I'm a rebel.

Best Multiplayer

Battlefield Bad Company 2. The great physics and improved destruction make it even better than the original.

]Lead and Gold: Gangss of the Wild West. Despite small player community, frequent disconnects, and lack of an upgrade system, this game managed to be FUCKING FUN!! Enemies were too durable, matchmaking was sad, graphics were meh, but somehow you don't care. The balance is great, maps are fun, and every class has a purpose.

Socom: Confrontation. I don't know, I liked it. Can't really defend it, but it's my fucking list.

Best most "Everything I just did in the game was pointless story-wise"

I don't play enough sanboxes, so all I got is Red Faction Guerilla.

Best game of 2000-2009
Too tough to choose, and my tastes change too often!
Top 5 RPG

Baldurs Gate: Dark Alliance. First rpg, and great combat.

Oblivion. Loved the open world, and the archery.

Most heart-breaking game

I'm a manly man!

Best FPS

BFBC2, said it before, plus humor and amazing intro.

Medal of Honor: Airbourne. Don't know why this caught so much flak (geddit?) because the gameplay was fun and the lighting was brilliant. Sure the aiming was a little weird, but you got used to it.

Fuck, I can't think right now.


Most penguin-esque game

Definitly Burnout Paradise. No contenders

Most realistic(Sims don't count)
I don't really play realistic games, so...

Worst 5 games overall
Dark Void

Fuel

Dark Void
Top 5 games overall

My tastes change too often!

 

[rekabdarb]

While i'm prob not gonna add anything to this thread yet i would love to point out WHY you don't like final fantasy 7, and i commend you for it. You dislike it not because it's cool to like it, because of a valid reason

 

[Proverbial Jon]

Best multiplayer:
- Not much of a multiplayer fan

Best "everything I just did in that game was pointless"
- Just Cause 2!

Best game of 2000-2009
- Half Life 2 and Episodes (In terms of how well everything works. Great characters, great gameplay, great storyline, just great! Possibly to be considered one of the most perfect games.)

Top RPG:
- The Elder Scrolls: Oblivion

Most heart-breaking game:
- Metal Gear Solid 3

Top FPS:
- Half Life 2: Episode 2

Most pengiun-esque:
- Uhh?

Top immersive/Best Story
- Mass Effect 1 & 2

Most realistic game(Besides Sims)
- Condemned (Combat actually feels like you're hitting people and not just slapping them about)

Top 5 worst games overall
5 - Dead Rising
4 - Clive Barker's Jerico
3 - Anything to do with F.E.A.R.
2 - LOTR: Conquest
1 - Silent Hill: Homecoming

Top 5 best games overall
5 - Metal Gear Solid
4 - Alan Wake
3 - Halo: Combat Evolved
2 - Half Life 2: Episode 2
1 - Silent Hill 2

 

[GrinningManiac]

I know, I know this thread has been done before, but only part of it!


It's a simple thread, what are you top 5(Of all time) of my wonderful categories:
Best multiplayer

TF2

Best most "Everything I just did in the game was pointless story-wise"

InFamous

Best game of 2000-2009

Evil Genius (PC)

Top 5 RPG

Fallout 3 is the only one I really play

Most heart-breaking game

Beyond Good and Evil

Best FPS

TF2

Most penguin-esque game

TF2 if I stuck a picture of a penguin over the monitor

Most immersive/Best story

Fallout 3/Empire Total War (WITH MODS)

Most realistic(Sims don't count)

Sims 3, f*ck you!

Worst 5 games overall

GODDAMN F*CKING "SPORE"
Empire: Total War
Generic Shooter : Now With More Arabs
Sims 2 (later expansions)
Napoleon Total War (so goddamn stale)

Top 5 games overall

Evil Genius
Black and White 2
LittleBigPlanet
Beyond Good and Evil
The Sims

 

[Skeleton Jelly]

Holy Jesus here I go.

Best multiplayer:

Team Fortress 2

Best most "Everything I just did in the game was pointless story-wise"
Fallout 3...really maybe about 1/5 of the game was about the actual storyline

Best game of 2000-2009

Baten Kaitos. Just because I could never put it down for 1 second and it was perfect in almost every way.

Top 5 RPG

Baten Kaitos and Baten Kaitos Origins are tied for first. Mass Effect Series and I enjoyed Fallout 3 and am currently TRYING to get Fallout 2, cause it looks so much more interesting. Not 5, but oh well.

Most heart-breaking game

Everyone is going to hate me, but I'm seriously going to say CoD4. Because when Gaz, Griggs, got killed I was shitting brix. Then Price hands me the handgun and I was so damn stoked to kill those fuckers. Then I look over to Price expecting a "Good job mate." and all I got was a Russian soldier doing chest compressions on him. IW seriously built up some good characters in my opinion.

That or MORE BATEN KAITOS cause the ending almost made me shed man tears.

Best FPS

Oh geez. Either Condemned Criminal Origins, Serious Sam, Doom, or Bioshock.

Most penguin-esque game

Yeah I'm just going to skip that

Most immersive/Best story

Condemned Criminal Origins comes second to BATEN KAITOS.

Most realistic(Sims don't count)

Ummm. Counter Strike I guess.

Worst 5 games overall

Half Life series. And I'm completely serious. I'm not trying to be different, I just really hated all 4. And I hate it more because apparently it's sooo fucking amazing. But it's just my opinion. And F.E.A.R cause it bored me to hell and stopped being scary by the 2nd level.

Top 5 games overall

Condemned 1, Team Fortress 2, Timesplitters FP, Baten Kaitos, and Freedom Fighters. And I'm adding in Mass Effect 1 & 2 anyways.

I feel like I play too many new games and not enough of the classics ;_;

 

[Skeleton Jelly]

Holy Jesus here I go.

Best multiplayer:

Team Fortress 2

Best most "Everything I just did in the game was pointless story-wise"

Fallout 3...really maybe about 1/5 of the game was about the actual storyline

Best game of 2000-2009

Baten Kaitos. Just because I could never put it down for 1 second and it was perfect in almost every way.

Top 5 RPG

Baten Kaitos and Baten Kaitos Origins are tied for first. Mass Effect Series and I enjoyed Fallout 3 and am currently TRYING to get Fallout 2, cause it looks so much more interesting. Not 5, but oh well.

Most heart-breaking game

Everyone is going to hate me, but I'm seriously going to say CoD4. Because when Gaz, Griggs, got killed I was shitting brix. Then Price hands me the handgun and I was so damn stoked to kill those fuckers. Then I look over to Price expecting a "Good job mate." and all I got was a Russian soldier doing chest compressions on him. IW seriously built up some good characters in my opinion.

That or MORE BATEN KAITOS cause the ending almost made me shed man tears.

Best FPS

Oh geez. Either Condemned Criminal Origins, Serious Sam, Doom, or Bioshock.

Most penguin-esque game

Yeah I'm just going to skip that

Most immersive/Best story

Condemned Criminal Origins comes second to BATEN KAITOS.

Most realistic(Sims don't count)

Ummm. Counter Strike I guess.

Worst 5 games overall

Half Life series. And I'm completely serious. I'm not trying to be different, I just really hated all 4. And I hate it more because apparently it's sooo fucking amazing. But it's just my opinion. And F.E.A.R cause it bored me to hell and stopped being scary by the 2nd level.

Top 5 games overall

Condemned 1, Team Fortress 2, Timesplitters FP, Baten Kaitos, and Freedom Fighters. And I'm adding in Mass Effect 1 & 2 anyways.

I feel like I play too many new games and not enough of the classics ;_;

 

[Skeleton Jelly]

Holy Jesus here I go.

Best multiplayer:

Team Fortress 2

Best most "Everything I just did in the game was pointless story-wise"

Fallout 3...really maybe about 1/5 of the game was about the actual storyline

Best game of 2000-2009

Baten Kaitos. Just because I could never put it down for 1 second and it was perfect in almost every way.

Top 5 RPG

Baten Kaitos and Baten Kaitos Origins are tied for first. Mass Effect Series and I enjoyed Fallout 3 and am currently TRYING to get Fallout 2, cause it looks so much more interesting. Not 5, but oh well.

Most heart-breaking game

Everyone is going to hate me, but I'm seriously going to say CoD4. Because when Gaz, Griggs, got killed I was shitting brix. Then Price hands me the handgun and I was so damn stoked to kill those fuckers. Then I look over to Price expecting a "Good job mate." and all I got was a Russian soldier doing chest compressions on him. IW seriously built up some good characters in my opinion.

That or MORE BATEN KAITOS cause the ending almost made me shed man tears.

Best FPS

Oh geez. Either Condemned Criminal Origins, Serious Sam, Doom, or Bioshock.

Most penguin-esque game

Yeah I'm just going to skip that

Most immersive/Best story

Condemned Criminal Origins comes second to BATEN KAITOS.

Most realistic(Sims don't count)

Ummm. Counter Strike I guess.

Worst 5 games overall

Half Life series. And I'm completely serious. I'm not trying to be different, I just really hated all 4. And I hate it more because apparently it's sooo fucking amazing. But it's just my opinion. And F.E.A.R cause it bored me to hell and stopped being scary by the 2nd level.

Top 5 games overall

Condemned 1, Team Fortress 2, Timesplitters FP, Baten Kaitos, and Freedom Fighters. And I'm adding in Mass Effect 1 & 2 anyways.

I feel like I play too many new games and not enough of the classics ;_;

 

[Skeleton Jelly]

Harr haarrr. Check my triples.

 

[Jonesy911]

"Top 5 worst games overall
1.Final fantasy 7(Because it spawned the thing we now know as "Fanboys", and made every JRPG follow suit in design.)"

Not only is this wrong (fan boys have been around for AGES!) but its not the games fault it was so successfull, obviously with that kind of success you're going to get copy cats