Wow I loved this review!!! Silent Hill 2 is one of my favorite games of all time too, playing to get all 6 endings as well as Maria's side story was so great.
He's right about everything, James is actually a very interesting character and really fits well with the game, Pyramid Head truly was terrifying and at his best in this game only, and the atmosphere of all the settings was truly something.
Now I miss this game, I wish I still had it, now I want it, I had the original case and everything...
Today's my birthday and obviously Yahtzee doesn't know me but I'm going to pretend this review is a birthday present to me ^^ lol
Great review, really enjoyed it
EDIT!!!: Anyone who actually played SH2 should recognize his reference at the end. At the beginning of SH2 you find a bar with a map pointing out a location for you to visit and on the wall there is some writing in red (blood?) that says "THERE WAS A HOLE HERE. IT'S GONE NOW."
Damn nice one Yahtzee, good reference, now I wanna get this game again once I get a 360.