What really bothers me is this argument that the Wii should be a 1:1 machine. Go ahead have a 12 year old golf like they really would. Think you can serve like Andy Roddick? Lol, no. Or perhaps you would like resistance behind your sword every time you hit someone? Guess you are going to be playing about a half level a day because there is no way you are going to be hacking shrubbery looking for gems like in the original Zelda....your arm would fall off. So perhaps it is time to realize it is a game console, not an everything simulator, and perhaps the motions are a little more enjoyable than the "skill" required to play the games Yahtzee showed in the video. Those skills being....memorizing the timing of button presses and combinations, plus a bit of muscle memory for moving the analog sticks. Wait....oh the Wii just uses memorization of timing for specific motions, and a tons of muscle memory....clearly far less "skill."
When I go to swipe a ball in 3 on 3 basketball in Wii resort, I wag the Wiimote. Yeah not a full swiping motion, but if it was on Xbox 360 your thumb would move a millimeter. Not to mention....I can play against other people in the same room. The horror! I am still convinced that Natal will require everyone to game in separate rooms. 1:1 is not fun. Maybe some simulator type games would be good, but just accept it is still a game. Take a moment sometime when you are playing some wonderful deep game and look at what you are doing with your hands (likely twiddling one thumb while mashing buttons with the other....in the same repetitive motion).
The motion plus is like adding a bunch of buttons to a controller. Suddenly there are more options to make your GAME a little more complex. That is the strength of Wii Sports Resort, everything is a little more complex than in all the other Wii games. Yes the games do not have the depth of a dedicated sports title, but until that EA basketball game come out....this is the next best thing.
No I am not a Nintendo fanboy. I have played a total of 10 games on Wii, not all are great. I am primarily a hardcore high end PC gamer. The amount of irrational hate and lack of real discussion about the Wii is just infuriating to me. You wonder why every game is the same Yahtzee, read the comments on your reviews..........