Representative government is the dumbest form of government only after the category I dubbed dictatorship by group or by a single person. And the American form of government is among its dumbest adopters.
Just think, you can elect your reps, but you can't recall them, and even if you can, the position of saying congressional representative is less well paid than the lobbyist or corporate board position they take after getting the job, getting voted out again, or etc. Also, where is the check on someone like Sinema or most others who don't keep their promises, and straight-up lie to the American people, then likely get a corporate position in big pharma after lying, and acting like a sham representative.
Also dumb is democratic socialists, social democrats who say let's keep the conservative sham"representative democratic system" currently being exploited by profiteers in the US system, but also in various countries like Hungry(which started out as a rep. democracy), Brazil, and South Korea. Why would you play by their rules? Why would you not try to push things on a micro-scale of pushing policies that help individual people, and also not try to change the very system that infects, and distorts the will of the people on a macro level, or even international level?
You want to abolish capitalism, but you don't want to abolish the system that will enable capitalism to come back stronger than ever in a bougie counter-revolution every electoral cycle once liberal obstructionists and conservatives team up, and destroy your progressive agency. (what would have happened if Bernie had won)
Well, Gergar12 we could do what Singapore does which is to pay our reps a million dollars or more salary, have the president be paid 26 million a year(not exactly crazy given how important his job is, and how many CEOs of much less important organizations get paid). Great now our officials are the new nobles. Well, we could reform X, Y, or Z. Which will be countered by a bougie counter-revolution/a win of a more conservative head of state, and or legislature.
Well, Gergar12, direct democracy could overthrow itself, progressive policies, or just vote bad shit in. Which we already have, and I argue this would occur less in a direct democracy than in this sham, oligarchic, elitist, fake democracy we have in the US, and around the world.
Well, Gergar12 people are too dumb to vote in their leaders, which is why we should educate them, and slowly phased in direct democracy to get people used to the idea, instead of relying on Jake Tapper, Rachel Maddow, or Tucker Carlson to get our information from, then vote for people who then lie to you.