Still going through Path of Radiance, I've now completed the pair of ship missions. I'm going to broadly divide my thoughts this time in accordance with their respective areas:
GAMEPLAY
-Boyd's still my MVP. I know that, because for the last few missions Soren's battle report has designated him as such, but still, he's probably my most valuable unit at this point (yes, even more than Ike).
-So I recruited Jill, and...okay, I know a lot of people like Jill as a character (I do, certainly), but as a unit? Compared to Marcia, despite being at similar levels at this point, Jill just comes off as a less efficient version of Marcia (odd, since wyvern riders are usually better than pegasus knights in my experience). Considering the nature of the ship missions, flyers are of course valuable, but the difference is that Marcia usually manages to hit her foes, while Jill doesn't.
-So I recruited Astrid (fun fact, she'll almost certainly die in the first turn of the second ship mission if you don't act quickly), and...oh. Level 1. Yikes. I certainly don't see much point in levelling up Sothe (even if having two thieves was useful in the second ship mission), but I'm torn as to whether I should level up Astrid or not.
-In what's probably against the grain...I'll say it, Brom's actually pretty useful. He's nothing special, and is outshone by Gatrie (who of course, is back in the party now), but as a damage sponge? Yeah, he's got his money's worth. I really don't get why so many people disregard him.
STORY
-I can't help but wonder about the Laguzslayer sword that you can equip characters with. I'm sure Lethe and Mordecai have absolutely nothing to say on that...
-Oh Sanaki, you little scamp.
-I'm going to say something else that may ruffle a few feathers, but this far into the game, I really don't like Elincia as a character. It's not necessarily bad writing, but so far, almost all she's done is just be meek (her sprite represents this), say "oh, my Lord Ike" over and over, and be passive while more assertive characters are around her. This, despite the fact that the main goal of the story at this point (heck, the story as a whole) is reclaiming Crimea, yet as an individual, she's not really doing anything about it.
Now you may say in response that her meekness is the point. Elincia grew up sheltered, hidden from the world, was never intended for the throne, and she's been thrust into circumstances beyond her control. All of that is correct, but multiple chapters on, and over two months having passed in-universe, she's still the same meek girl that Ike and co. found way earlier. You could make the argument that Path of Radiance should actually be Elincia's story rather than Ike's, but the difference is that Ike is a compelling protagonist, while Elincia is just a doormat.
-Other people have explained this better than I have, but basically, when it comes to FE stories, there generally seems to be a spectrum of how far said stories lean towards the fantastical as opposed to the political, with most having a mix of the two. Out of all the FE games I've played to whatever extent (FE6-9, 11), PoR is easily the most political of the bunch, at least of what I've played so far. This doesn't necessarily make it better or worse than the others (e.g. FE7's focus is on telling a smaller, very personal story, and accomplishes it), but it's something I think the game has done exceptionally well so far, especially when it comes to the sense of realpolitik. I'm skipping ahead slightly, but at this time of playing, here's the in-universe situation as it stands:
1: Daein has invaded Crimea, decimiating its army and put it under occupation.
2: Gallia, despite having an alliance with Crimea, can't help, because despite Cannhegis's sympathies, realpolitik prevents him from acting since most laguz hate beorc (and vice versa)
3: Goldoa remains in firm isolation, while Phoenecis and Nevassa don't care about a beorc war.
4: Bengnion, the most powerful country on the continent, has no reason whatsoever to aid Elincia and Crimea, since they stand to gain nothing, and Elincia's claim is highly tenuous.
To be clear, I'm not saying that PoR is some kind of in-depth look at war and politics (it's no A Song of Ice and Fire for instance), but by the standards of the series and most games in general? Pretty well done. It's actually refreshing to see so much cynicism in the world, where despite Daein's attrocities, the reaction of every other monarch is "fuck you, got mine."
So, yeah. Pretty neat. Could see FE10 surpassing FE7 for me, which means it enters my top ten GOAT list, and would be high on an RPG list, so, um, yeah.