Ukraine

Thaluikhain

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 16, 2010
19,005
3,760
118
The question isn't whether or not the invasion is justified
There's still people arguing it was justified, it's still somehow a question.

The U.S. is funding a war that benefits only its rich
It benefits various rich people in the US, in this case to help prevent innocent Ukranians being slaughtered. It also helps prevent innocent Ukranians being slaughtered.
 

TheMysteriousGX

Elite Member
Legacy
Sep 16, 2014
8,456
7,020
118
Country
United States
That's certainly a lot of talking that doesn't justify a Russian invasion of Ukraine, holy shit. I'm still not making the connection between "the US sucks" and "therefore it's good that Russia is lobbing cruise missiles into Kyiv"
 

Terminal Blue

Elite Member
Legacy
Feb 18, 2010
3,914
1,781
118
Country
United Kingdom
Russia was very weak during the 1990s
Relative to what?

Russia still ended up with a disproportionately giant stockpile of military equipment including nuclear weapons and ICBMs. Russia has never had to worry about any hypothetical possibility of ever having its sovereignty threatened by military invasion, even from a global superpower like the US or China, because not even a superpower can laugh off the risk of being turned into radioactive dust. NATO expansion doesn't threaten Russia in the slightest, what it threatens is the ability of Russia to use those enormous stockpiles of military equipment to exert power over neighboring countries.

In addition, why didn't the U.S. and others respond militarily when Russia attacked Georgia?
Again, Russia was seen as an important strategic ally in the so-called War on Terror. Its routine military interventions in neighboring states were seen as consistent with the prevailing US foreign policy concern of preventing the spread of Islamism.

But this isn't about the supposed moral responsibilities of the US, it's about the realities of resistance to colonialism. I dislike the political system of my country quite intensely, but if an invading army showed up in my country, dropped bombs on houses and went around indiscriminately killing, raping and torturing people, then abstract questions of political justice or the unfairness of the global order would very quickly stop mattering. Expecting people who have endured this, or who face the very real threat of it happening to them, to spend any time pondering about whether some other country has hypothetically also done bad things elsewhere is ridiculous.

Put simply, it's U.S. exceptionalism, we're good, and everyone else isn't. That's basically it.
I'm not from the US, and I don't consider any existing or historical government to be or have ever been good. There is no such thing as harmless power.

I protested my government's involvement in the so-called War on Terror at a time when most people, and certainly the political establishment, still supported it. As frustrating as it is to see those responsible go unpunished, it is nonetheless undeniable at this point that those of us who objected to those conflicts have absolutely won the national debate both here and in the US. For the wrong reasons, certainly. I know very well that opposition has more to do with strategic failures than it does with any real principles, but at least we got there for now.

But I didn't protest American neocolonialism in the middle east because the wrong people were doing the colonizing, I did it because colonialism is evil. It is an ideological disease that has no place in the world, and anything that brings us closer to the day when the entire rotted idea is banished to the dustbin of history is good.

As for American exceptionalism, I've made very clear where I think it lies in this argument. I think American exceptionalism is believing that only Americans are capable of any form of agency or responsibility, that morality only matters when it concerns Americans. The antithesis to American exceptionalism isn't the belief in some unique or exceptional evil of which only America is capable, it is the realization that America is not a special country and its people are not special people. Americans are exactly the same as the rest of us, with the same capacity and incentives towards good or evil, the same susceptibility to ideological delusion and failure. The 7.5 billion people on earth who are not Americans are just as important, just as capable of acting in their own interests and just as capable of moral conduct as the just over 300 million who are.
 
Last edited:

Absent

And twice is the only way to live.
Jan 25, 2023
1,594
1,557
118
Country
Switzerland
Gender
The boring one
There's still people arguing it was justified, it's still somehow a question.
With degrees of that. Justified, excused, etc... But a lot of people do technically side for the bigger evil to spite the lesser one. Also a lot of people "exist" through that in a way similar to antivaxxers or flatearthers (self-flattering thrill of enlightened happy few). Also a lot of people have a basic self-identification to hard right strongmen à la Trump, Putin, etc.
 

Ag3ma

Elite Member
Jan 4, 2023
2,574
2,208
118
Unfunded liabilities refer to future costs that can't be covered. That's besides the accumulated debt.
No, unfunded liabilities are future costs that are not currently covered. They can be, either through reducing those costs or expanding revenue to cover them. Of course, revenue should theoretically increase, if nothing else by continuing GDP growth. With an average 2% GDP growth and consistent tax incomes, real terms revenue should double in about 35 years.

Much of this is due to the harsh realities of an ageing population, as government costs tend to go up (pensions, healthcare) with age, outpacing the increase in revenue from the working age population. This will ultimately force governments to reassess their tax and spend plans, but this is the standard work of governments.

And this isn't just a problem for the USA. Take a look at China's projected population change. Likewise consider whether the likes of China, with increased development, will be able to maintain their relatively modest pension and medical spending - because it's very unlikely that they will avoid substantial spending increases on them. Consequently, as we're talking about the relative strengths and weaknesses of countries, the USA's rivals have their own obstacles to overcome.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: thestor

Ag3ma

Elite Member
Jan 4, 2023
2,574
2,208
118
Russia was very weak during the 1990s, which is why they wanted assurance from the U.S. that NATO would not move one inch forward. It went against that because Clinton decided to engage in electioneering:
Yes, Russia was weak. Actually, it still is.

But from the instant the USSR broke apart, Russia set about maintaining forms of control. For instance, the reason Transnistria is autonomous from Moldova is that upon the dissolution of the USSR, Russian army units blocked Moldovan control of the area. Russia has subsequently suppressed an internal independence movement with shocking brutality, invaded at least two of its neighbours, and blatantly attempted to control others through fossil fuels, destabilisation, massive political and media interferences, etc.

Russia has never stopped being or acting like an imperial power. It's just having a lot more trouble holding onto its imperial possessions than it used to.

There's your problem: for you this issue isn't complex or nuanced. You remind me of Reagan, with his reductionist views of "evil empires," and Dubya, who has a binary view of the world, such that you're either with us or with the terrorists. Put simply, it's U.S. exceptionalism, we're good, and everyone else isn't. That's basically it.
Trite and inaccurate.

Most of the people in this forum have a reasonably consistent attutide to imperialism: it's bad. They opposed the West in Afghanistan and Iraq and they oppose Russia in Ukraine. There is nothing like the defence of the USA that you have fantasised.

That said, I personally think the USA really is a great deal better than Russia in most respects - rule of law, human rights, etc.
 

Avnger

Trash Goblin
Legacy
Apr 1, 2016
2,113
1,237
118
Country
United States
There's your problem: for you this issue isn't complex or nuanced. You remind me of Reagan, with his reductionist views of "evil empires," and Dubya, who has a binary view of the world, such that you're either with us or with the terrorists. Put simply, it's U.S. exceptionalism, we're good, and everyone else isn't. That's basically it.
And this is where we've reached the pure projection stage.

See, that's actually your problem. It's just that rather than engaging in US exceptionalism, you're engaging in "anti-US" exceptionalism. It's the exact same imperialist philosophy (ignoring the agency/sovereignty of smaller nations, believing in spheres of influence, believing might makes right), but the core foundation is reversed to be "anti-US is good and everyone else isn't".

What you either can't or won't comprehend is that most of this forum is (beyond a few extremists such as yourself) anti-imperialist regardless of the nation. The US is bad when it engages in imperialism. Similarly, Russia, China, France, the UK, etc are all bad when they engage in imperialism. When a country takes imperialist actions, it does not deserve a freebie (or, in this case, pages upon pages of apologetics) just because they happen to be acting against US interests while doing so.
 

XsjadoBlaydette

~s•o√r∆rπy°`
May 26, 2022
1,094
1,376
118
Clear 'n Present Danger
Country
Must
Gender
Disappear
Whoopsie Doodles





Article link: https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2023/04/12/discord-leaked-documents/

The man behind a massive leak of U.S. government secrets that has exposed spying on allies, revealed the grim prospects for Ukraine’s war with Russia and ignited diplomatic fires for the White House is a young, charismatic gun enthusiast who shared highly classified documents with a group of far-flung acquaintances searching for companionship amid the isolation of the pandemic.

United by their mutual love of guns, military gear and God, the group of roughly two dozenmostly men and boys — formed an invitation-only clubhouse in 2020 on Discord, an online platform popular with gamers. But they paid little attention last year when the man some call “OG” posted a message laden with strange acronyms and jargon. The words were unfamiliar, and few people read the long note, one of the members explained. But he revered OG, the elder leader of their tiny tribe, who claimed to know secrets that the government withheld from ordinary people.

The young member read OG’s message closely, and the hundreds more that he said followed on a regular basis for months. They were, he recalled, what appeared to be near-verbatim transcripts of classified intelligence documents that OG indicated he had brought home from his job on a “military base,” which the member declined to identify. OG claimed he spent at least some of his day inside a secure facility that prohibited cellphones and other electronic devices, which could be used to document the secret information housed on government computer networks or spooling out from printers. He annotated some of the hand-typed documents, the member said, translating arcane intel-speak for the uninitiated, such as explaining that “NOFORN” meant the information in the document was so sensitive it must not be shared with foreign nationals.


OG told the group he toiled for hours writing up the classified documents to share with his companions in the Discord server he controlled. The gathering spot had been a pandemic refuge, particularly for teen gamers locked in their houses and cut off from their real-world friends. The members swapped memes, offensive jokes and idle chitchat. They watched movies together, joked around and prayed. But OG also lectured them about world affairs and secretive government operations. He wanted to “keep us in the loop,” the member said, and seemed to think that his insider knowledge would offer the others protection from the troubled world around them.

“He’s a smart person. He knew what he was doing when he posted these documents, of course. These weren’t accidental leaks of any kind,” the member said.

The transcribed documents OG posted traversed a range of sensitive subjects that only people who had undergone months-long background checks would be authorized to see. There were top-secret reports about the whereabouts and movements of high-ranking political leaders and tactical updates on military forces, the member said. Geopolitical analysis. Insights into foreign governments’ efforts to interfere with elections. “If you could think it, it was in those documents.”

In those initial posts, OG had given his fellow members a small sip of the torrent of secrets that was to come. When rendering hundreds of classified files by hand proved too tiresome, he began posting hundreds of photos of documents themselves, an astonishing cache of secrets that has been steadily spilling into public view over the past week, disrupting U.S. foreign policy and aggravating America’s allies.

This account of how detailed intelligence documents intended for an exclusive circle of military leaders and government decision-makers found their way into and then out of OG’s closed community is based in part on several lengthy interviews with the Discord group member, who spoke to The Washington Post on the condition of anonymity. He is under 18 and was a young teenager when he met OG. The Post obtained consent from the member’s mother to speak to him and to record his remarks on video. He asked that his voice not be obscured.

His account was corroborated by a second member who read many of the same classified documents shared by OG, and who also spoke on the condition of anonymity. Both members said they know OG’s real name as well as the state where he lives and works but declined to share that information while the FBI is hunting for the source of the leaks. The investigation is in its early stages, and the Pentagon has set up its own internal review led by a senior official.

“An interagency effort has been stood up, focused on assessing the impact these photographed documents could have on U.S. national security and on our Allies and partners,” Pentagon deputy press secretary Sabrina Singh said in a statement.

Discord said in a statement that it is cooperating with law enforcement and has declined to comment further.

The Post also reviewed approximately 300 photos of classified documents, most of which have not been made public; some of the text documents OG is said to have written out; an audio recording of a man the two group members identified as OG speaking to his companions; and chat records and photographs that show OG communicating with them on the Discord server.

The young member was impressed by OG’s seemingly prophetic ability to forecast major events before they became headline news, things “only someone with this kind of high clearance” would know. He was by his own account enthralled with OG, who he said was in his early to mid-20s.

“He’s fit. He’s strong. He’s armed. He’s trained. Just about everything you can expect out of some sort of crazy movie,” the member said.


In a video seen by The Post, the man who the member said is OG stands at a shooting range, wearing safety glasses and ear coverings and holding a large rifle. He yells a series of racial and antisemitic slurs into the camera, then fires several rounds at a target.

The member seemed drawn to OG’s bravado and his skill with weapons. He felt a certain kinship with a man he described as “like an uncle” and, on another occasion, as a father figure.

“I was one of the very few people in the server that was able to understand that these [documents] were legitimate,” the member said, setting himself apart from the others who mostly ignored OG’s posts.

“It felt like I was on top of Mount Everest,” he said. “I felt like I was above everyone else to some degree and that … I knew stuff that they didn’t.”

‘A tightknit family’


The member met OG about four years ago, on a different server for fans of Oxide, a popular YouTuber who streams videos about guns, body armor and military hardware. He said a group of avid members found the server too crowded and wanted a quieter place to talk about video game tactics, so they broke off into their own, small group.

More like-minded Oxide fans joined the private Discord server, which came to be named “Thug Shaker Central,” and whose membership OG would effectively control as the administrator.

“We all grew very close to each other, like a tightknit family,” the member said. “We depended on each other.” He said that other members, and OG especially, counseled him during bouts of depression and helped to steady him emotionally. “There was no lack of love for each other.”

OG was the undisputed leader. The member described him as “strict.” He enforced a “pecking order” and expected the others to read closely the classified information he had shared. When their attention waned, he got angry.

More on the Discord leaks

No Russia-Ukraine peace talks expected this year, U.S. leak shows
No Russia-Ukraine peace talks expected this year, U.S. leak shows

Leak of military secrets on Discord marks a new step for social media
Leak of military secrets on Discord marks a new step for social media

Leaked Pentagon documents claim that hackers breached a Canadian gas network. Here’s what to know.
Leaked Pentagon documents claim that hackers breached a Canadian gas networ...
Analysis

CIA leak, sanctions highlight strained relations between U.S. and Hungary
CIA leak, sanctions highlight strained relations between U.S. and Hungary

How U.S. friends and foes have responded to leaked Pentagon documents
How U.S. friends and foes have responded to leaked Pentagon documents

Egypt secretly planned to supply rockets to Russia, leaked U.S. document says
Egypt secretly planned to supply rockets to Russia, leaked U.S. document sa...

Israeli spy chiefs led secret revolt against Netanyahu overhaul plans, leaked documents say
Israeli spy chiefs led secret revolt against Netanyahu overhaul plans, leak...

Leaked documents warn of weaknesses in Ukraine’s defenses
Leaked documents warn of weaknesses in Ukraine’s defenses

Intelligence leak exposes U.S. spying on adversaries and allies
Intelligence leak exposes U.S. spying on adversaries and allies

Justice Dept. will investigate leak of classified Pentagon documents
Justice Dept. will investigate leak of classified Pentagon documents



Late last year, a peeved OG fired off a message to all the members of the server. He had spent nearly an hour every day writing up “these long and drawn-out posts in which he’d often add annotations and explanations for stuff that we normal citizens would not understand,” the member said. His would-be pupils were more interested in YouTube videos about battle gear.

“He got upset, and he said on multiple occasions, if you guys aren’t going to interact with them, I’m going to stop sending them.”

That’s when OG changed tactics. Rather than spend his time copying documents by keyboard, he took photographs of the genuine articles and dropped them in the server. These were more vivid and arresting documents than the plain text renderings. Some featured detailed charts of battlefield conditions in Ukraine and highly classified satellite images of the aftermath of Russian missile strikes on Ukrainian electrical facilities. Others sketched the potential trajectory of North Korean ballistic nuclear missiles that could reach the United States. Another featured photographs of the Chinese spy balloon that floated across the country in February, snapped from eye-level, probably by a U-2 spy plane, along with a diagram of the balloon and the surveillance technology attached to it.


OG shared several documents a week, beginning late last year. Posting pictures to the server took less time. But it also exposed OG to greater risk. In the background of some images, they could see items and furniture that they recognized from the room where OG spoke to them via video on the Discord channel — the kind of clues that could prove useful for federal investigators.

The dramatic and yet nonchalant presentation also reminded the group that OG could lay his hands on some of the most closely guarded intelligence in the U.S. government. “If you had classified documents, you’d want to flex at least a little bit, like hey, I’m the big guy,” the member said. “There is a little bit of showing off to friends, but as well as wanting to keep us informed.”

In a sense, OG had created a virtual mirror image of the secretive facility where he spent his working hours. Inside the Discord server, he was the ultimate arbiter of secrecy, and he allowed his companions to read truths that “normal citizens” could not.

A breach of secrecy

The photographs of printed secret documents now seen by millions may offer clues to the federal agents searching for OG. Reality Winner, who leaked secret National Security Agency documents to the news website the Intercept in 2017, was compromised by secret markings on printouts that helped narrow the search. OG’s documents look to have been printed on ordinary paper and were creased after having been folded in four. Sometimes, the photographs OG took of the documents appeared to have been taken over a bed. Items such as Gorilla Glue, a scope manual and nail clippers appeared in the margins. Other previously unreported images reviewed by The Post showed printed documents lying on top of a glowing red keyboard.

The breadth of the military and intelligence reports was extensive. For months, OG regularly uploaded page after page of classified U.S. assessments, offering a window into how deeply American intelligence had penetrated the Russian military, showing that Egypt had planned to sell Russia tens of thousands of rockets and suggesting that Russian mercenaries had approached Turkey, a NATO ally, to buy weapons to fight against Ukraine.

1681391325284.png
Egyptian President Abdel Fatah El-Sisi, left, with Russian President Vladimir Putin in 2018. Among the leaked documents were a U.S. military assessment that Egypt planned to sell Russia tens of thousands of rockets as Moscow wages war in Ukraine. (Alexei Druzhinin/Sputnik/Pool/AP)


At least one of the documents appeared to have been printed from Intellipedia, a data-sharing system that intelligence agencies use to collaborate and post reports and articles.

The documents were another lesson for younger members in how OG thought the world really worked. The member said OG wasn’t hostile to the U.S. government, and he insisted that he was not working on behalf of any country’s interests. “He is not a Russian operative. He is not a Ukrainian operative,” the member said. The room on the server where he posted the documents was called “bear-vs-pig,” meant to be a snide jab at Russia and Ukraine, and an indication that OG took no sides in the conflict.

But OG had a dark view of the government. The young member said he spoke of the United States, and particularly law enforcement and the intelligence community, as a sinister force that sought to suppress its citizens and keep them in the dark. He ranted about “government overreach.”

OG told his online companions that the government hid horrible truths from the public. He claimed, according to the members, that the government knew in advance that a white supremacist intended to go on a shooting rampage at a Buffalo supermarket in May 2022. The attack left 10 dead, all of them Black, and wounded three more. OG said federal law enforcement officials let the killings proceed so they could argue for increased funding, a baseless notion that the member said he believes and considers an example of OG’s penetrating insights about the depth of government corruption.

OG’s group itself had a dark side. The Discord server’s eventual name, Thug Shaker Central, was a racist allusion, and signaled to members that they were free to hurl epithets and crude jokes. The young member expressed some regret for their behavior but seemed to shrug off the offensive remarks as a clumsy attempt at humor.

It was not “a fascist recruiting server,” he told The Post.

One thing the members were not supposed to do was talk about the secrets OG had shared with them, including the classified documents.

“Most people in the server were smart enough as to kind of realize that … they shouldn’t be posted anywhere else,” the member said. And yet, the group contained foreign citizens — including from Russia and Ukraine, the members said — a defiance of the NOFORN warning printed across the top of so many documents OG shared.

The member estimated that the server hosted people from Europe, Asia and South America. “Just about every walk of life.” Of the roughly 25 active members who had access to the bear-vs-pig channel, about half were located overseas, the member said. The ones who seemed most interested in the classified material claimed to be from mostly “Eastern Bloc and those post-Soviet countries,” he said. “The Ukrainians had interest as well,” which the member chalked up to interest in the war ravaging their homeland.

For years, U.S. counterintelligence officials have eyed gaming platforms as a magnet for spies. Russian intelligence operatives have been suspected of befriending gamers who they believe work for intelligence agencies and encouraging them to divulge classified information, a senior U.S. official said, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss sensitive information.

It’s not clear whether any of those efforts have been successful. But if foreign operatives finagled an invitation to OG’s server, they would have been free to view the documents and make copies of them, as some members did.

1681391407427.png
A Ukrainian soldier carries away an artillery shell casing during fighting last month in the country’s eastern Donetsk region. Some of the leaked documents that allegedly were posted in the private space by OG offered detailed assessments of Ukraine’s defense capabilities. (Heidi Levine for The Washington Post)


The server sprouts a leak

All winter, OG uploaded documents to the server. No one talked about sharing them elsewhere. Then, unbeknown to the group, on Feb. 28, another teenage user from the Thug Shaker Central server began posting several dozen photographs showing classified documents on another Discord server affiliated with the YouTuber “wow_mao.” Some of the documents offered detailed assessments of Ukraine’s defense capabilities and showed how far U.S. intelligence could see into Russia’s military command.

On March 4, 10 documents appeared on “Minecraft Earth Map,” a Discord server focused on the popular video game. A user operating the account that posted the smaller tranche of images told The Post they obtained them on wow_mao.

Secret and top-secret documents were now available to thousands of Discord users, but the leak wouldn’t come to the attention of U.S. authorities for another month. Meanwhile, OG stopped sharing images in the middle of March. On April 5, classified documents assessing the war in Ukraine were posted on Russian Telegram channels and the message board platform 4chan, and began migrating to Twitter. One image, showing a March 1 Ukraine status update, had been crudely doctored to inflate the number of Ukrainian casualties and downplay those on the Russian side.

The next day, shortly before the New York Times first reported on the leak, OG came into the server “frantic, which is unusual for him,” the member said.

“He said something had happened, and he prayed to God that this event would not happen. … But now it’s in God’s hands.”

Not a whistleblower

For all OG’s disdain for the federal government, the member said there was no indication that he was acting in what he thought was the public interest by exposing official secrets. The classified documents were intended only to benefit his online family, the member said.

“I would definitely not call him a whistleblower. I would not call OG a whistleblower in the slightest,” he said, resisting comparisons to Edward Snowden, who shared classified documents about government surveillance with journalists.

Remarkably, the member said he has been in touch with OG in the past few days, even as an FBI manhunt is underway and the Pentagon launches its own inquiry into the leaks. After shuttering the Thug Shaker Central server, OG moved the community to another server to communicate with his online family.

He “seemed very confused and lost as to what to do,” the member said. “He’s fully aware of what’s happening and what the consequences may be. He’s just not sure on how to go about solving this situation. … He seems pretty distraught about it.”

In his final message to his companions, OG admonished them to “keep low and delete any information that could possibly relate to him,” the member said. That included any copies of the classified documents OG had shared.

When it dawned on them that OG was in grave peril and intended to disappear, the members of Thug Shaker Central “full-on sobbed and cried,” the young member said. “It is like losing a family member.”

In hours of interviews, he continued to express admiration and loyalty to a man who may have endangered his young followers by allowing them to see and possess classified information, exposing them to potential federal crimes.

“I figured he would not be putting us in any sort of harm’s way,” the member said.

The exposure of the documents has severed friendships and cut him off from the man who buoyed his confidence and made him feel safe. The member said that the stress of the loss, coupled with the enormity of the leaks, has left him worried and sleepless.

Now he says he believes that the world should see the secrets OG passed along to a tiny group. He argued that the public deserves to know how intelligence agencies spend their tax dollars, and was particularly outraged that the documents show U.S. surveillance of foreign allies.

But what the young man regarded as a revelation will come as no surprise to the countries whose officials the U.S. has been monitoring for decades. While rarely discussed, and embarrassing for Washington when exposed, it’s widely understood that the U.S. intelligence community monitors many friendly governments, just as foreign allies try to do the same.

Thousands of military personnel and government employees around OG’s age, working entry-to-low-level positions, could plausibly have access to classified documents like the ones he allegedly shared, according to U.S. officials and experts who have seen the documents reported in the media. Despite what his young followers thought, OG would have had no special knowledge compared with his peers. He possessed no special power to predict events. Rather, he appears to have persuaded some highly impressionable teenagers that he’s a modern-day gamer meets Jason Bourne.

The member said he’s confident the authorities will find OG. But when they do, he won’t be charged. Instead, he believes, OG will be imprisoned without due process at Guantánamo Bay or disappeared to a “black site,” if he’s not “assassinated” for what he knows.

The member, as well as the OG follower who corroborated his account, found no fault in their leader’s actions and instead said they blame the teen who posted the documents on the wow_mao server for wrecking their community.

“Maybe we should have had better opsec,” the member said, harnessing the jargon of military and intelligence personnel for “operations security.”

He said he will not divulge OG’s identity or location to law enforcement until he is captured or can flee the United States. “I think I might be detained eventually. … I think there might be a short investigation on how I knew this guy, and they’ll try to get something out of me. They might try to threaten me with prison time if I don’t reveal their identity.”

To date, no federal law enforcement officials have contacted the young group member. Asked why he was prepared to help OG even at the risk of his own freedom, the young man replied without hesitation: “He was my best friend.”
War Thunder forums got new competition on the block now.
 
Last edited:

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
11,830
6,179
118
Country
United Kingdom
NATO expansion would have included Ukraine. Putin did not allow for that.
You say it would.

Russian expansion would have included Ukraine. Ukrainians did not allow for that.

The point you're missing is that the country that's going against Russia was manipulated by the U.S.
Yes yes, I've heard this repeated over and over again, based on a relatively tiny amount of US money in Ukraine. Always overlooking the fact that Russian finance, military, and influence in Ukraine dwarfs it.

What about whataboutism and deflection? The Global South
^ irrelevant blather.

Why's that? Because they reject your accusations of whataboutism and deflection. For them, this issue is neither. That is, they're aware that Russia is manipulative and abusive, and even China. But there's a country that's more powerful than both and has done greater harm to them than either. Guess who?
....but you're not saying 'neither'. You're explicitly endorsing one specific coercive power invading, annexing and slaughtering an independent country.
 

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
11,830
6,179
118
Country
United Kingdom
That's because you comically missed a key part of Kennan's position, which is that the West should not interfere. Otherwise, there will be blowback.

Which is what you're seeing now.
How did I "miss" that exactly? I'm not the one holding him up as correct, so I'm not required to be in line with his thinking.

You, on the other hand, are the one that brought him up and lauded him... while simultaneously holding a position that's diametrically opposed to his.
 

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
11,830
6,179
118
Country
United Kingdom
Syria arches an eyebrow
Russia continues to commit war crimes in Syria via a neo-Nazi paramilitary and you couldn't give a shit.

You only care about the wellbeing of people in these countries as long as they can be used as a cudgel against America. The second one of your favoured perpetrators is involved, the line switches to excuses and defences for precisely the same (or worse) behaviour.
 
Last edited:

Ag3ma

Elite Member
Jan 4, 2023
2,574
2,208
118
Russia continues to commit war crimes in Syria via a neo-Nazi paramilitary and you couldn't give a shit.

You only care about the wellbeing of people in these countries as long as they can be used as a cudgel against America. The second one of your favoured perpetrators is involved, the line switches to excuses and defences for precisely the same (or worse) behaviour.
Of course, Syria continues to commit war crimes in Syria, and he couldn't give a shit about that either.
 

CM156

Resident Reactionary
Legacy
May 6, 2020
1,133
1,213
118
Country
United States
Gender
White Male
I can only speak for myself, but I oppose the bad things the USA does because the things are bad, not because it's the USA doing them.
As such, when other countries do the same things, I also oppose those.
I would hope that this could be a consistent stance that most people could take.
 

Hades

Elite Member
Mar 8, 2013
2,189
1,628
118
Country
The Netherlands
That's like saying that the U.S. has been a warmonger throughout its existence:
It has. No need to be shy about it. They didn't even move out of the founding fathers era without trying to anex Canada.

Though historically its (non Indian neighbors) had significantly less to fear from the US than eastern Europe did from Russia.

The last point is also raised by U.S. neocons, i.e., all countries against the U.S. want to form their own empires and must be stopped. Reagan referred to the Soviet Union then as the "evil empire." Later, Dubya argued that "you're either with us, or you're with the terrorists." Somehow, such a blinkered view of the world validates being a warmonger.
At the time the Soviets were busy terrorizing eastern Europe so I'm not sure we can hold it against Reagan for dubbing them so. Besides Russia ''defending itself from America'' in practice always results in Russia's neighbors having to hand over territory or sovereignty to Russia. As such no nation is obligated to help Russia ''defend'' itself because those nations will all be the first casualties of a secure Russia.

Besides what was so wrong about Russia's place in the post cold war world that they were ''forced'' to start a giant war and enact genocide against their neighbors? Russia was allowed to get filthy rich from gas and oil trades, while the west even looked the other way at Russia yet again invading their neighbors for a while. There was no accute danger or injustice for Russia to respond to. The only real restraint the west imposed on Russia was that it wasn't allowed to subjugate areas outside of Russia's legitimate borders and even that one proved pretty damned negotiable until very recently. Hardly the Carthaginian peace Russia simps insist Russia suffered under.
 
Last edited:

XsjadoBlaydette

~s•o√r∆rπy°`
May 26, 2022
1,094
1,376
118
Clear 'n Present Danger
Country
Must
Gender
Disappear
Took em longer than expected. The dude weren't subtle or clever with it lol.


Named Jack Teixeira, the national guardsman led Thug Shaker Central, an online group where about 20 to 30 people shared their love of guns, racist memes and video games, the Times said, citing interviews and documents it reviewed.