US 2024 Presidential Election

Seanchaidh

Elite Member
Legacy
Mar 21, 2009
5,886
3,572
118
Country
United States of America
Gratuitous for the purposes of oppressing Gaza and the West Bank, yes.

What, do you think America actually needs it's entire defence budget for its current engagements? That military capacity is only ever kept sky-high for immediate purposes? Come on. American assistance means they don't need to cause themselves as much economic discomfort to keep this going... and can hoard materiel for the future.
America is a country of 334 million people. The occupiers of Palestine have less than 10 million. In any case, 2000 and 500 pound bombs don't grow on olive trees.
 

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
12,411
6,504
118
Country
United Kingdom
Then I'll ask this as clearly as possible without any other talking points or messages to fuzzy it up

Why the FUCK could Biden not do this?

This isn't some brand new deal. According to the reports, this was the same exact deal offered to Israel and Hamas in July (that The Biden Administration claimed Israel accepted before we all found out that was a lie). ONE thing has changed in this situation and that's Trump waltzed in like the Chaotic Evil Force that he is and told Israel to take this deal or else.

Trump could be the devil incarnate (and he might be but that's a different discussion) but he is the one that stepped in and forced the deal according to every single report. So what is your thinking here?
I've already explained my perspective on the chain of events. Netanyahu was holding out in the hope that Trump would renegotiate more favourably to Israel. When it became clear that he wouldn't, Netanyahu took the existing offer.

He would have agreed (probably a bit earlier, on the same terms) had there not been an upcoming American election at all.

Like, I do not understand how you can be so blinded by your Blue Tinted Glasses that it can't even be possible that Trump did anything good (whatever his reasons, we'll see soon enough if this is all just bluster when Israel inevitably breaks the ceasefire because that's what Israel fucking does) and that Biden failed the hell out of Gaza and anyone with any sense of decency who stood up and cried out to have Biden do ANYTHING to stop the genocide. But here, since you're so desperate that Democrats get credit, they get credit for creating the deal in July. There, here is the sliver of credit they get for this ceasefire deal.
Dude, there's only so many times I can repeat that the Democrats' approach on this is repugnant and unacceptable. I've said so over and over again. I'm giving them no more credit than I'm giving Trump, because they've both done exactly the same fucking things with the same fucking terms.
 

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
12,411
6,504
118
Country
United Kingdom
America is a country of 334 million people. The occupiers of Palestine have less than 10 million.
Fail to see the relevance of this to the central point i made. As if a smaller occupying power somehow only has interest in military capacity for immediate needs, even if the opportunity exists to hoard it and get it cheaply.
 

tippy2k2

Beloved Tyrant
Legacy
Mar 15, 2008
14,806
2,256
118
I've already explained my perspective on the chain of events. Netanyahu was holding out in the hope that Trump would renegotiate more favourably to Israel. When it became clear that he wouldn't, Netanyahu took the existing offer.

He would have agreed (probably a bit earlier, on the same terms) had there not been an upcoming American election at all.



Dude, there's only so many times I can repeat that the Democrats' approach on this is repugnant and unacceptable. I've said so over and over again. I'm giving them no more credit than I'm giving Trump, because they've both done exactly the same fucking things with the same fucking terms.
Then maybe I'm the weirdo because I do not understand how anyone could possibly support Biden and The Democrats after it has become so clear that they could have stopped the genocide at any point and they actively chose not to (since again, this is the same exact deal Biden gave them in July). All it took was Trump putting the screws even just a little bit to Israel to get them to break (because they had zero leverage, it was all America giving and Israel taking) and Biden wouldn't even do the bare minimum to stop Israel from their genocide.

All the news sources have stated that Israel got the screws tightened at them by Trump. I thought plugging your ears and screaming FAKE NEWS!!!!! was supposed to be the MAGA thing but I suppose that's why we call you guys Blue MAGA. You do the same exact damn thing when the news sources make your party look like shit (or gives The Other Team credit for something good).
 
Last edited:

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
12,411
6,504
118
Country
United Kingdom
Then maybe I'm the weirdo because I do not understand how anyone could possibly support Biden and The Democrats after it has become so clear that they could have stopped the genocide at any point and they actively chose not to (since again, this is the same exact deal Biden gave them in July).
Depends what you mean by "support". Support him in what? I'm certainly not supporting his approach to Gaza.

All it took was Trump putting the screws even just a little bit to Israel to get them to break (because they had zero leverage, it was all America giving and Israel taking) and Biden wouldn't even do the bare minimum to stop Israel from their genocide.
Well, as I've said, i don't believe that's what happened. That's party spin, like Biden now trying to take credit.

All the news sources have stated that Israel got the screws tightened at them by Trump. I thought plugging your ears and screaming FAKE NEWS!!!!! was supposed to be the MAGA thing but I suppose that's why we call you guys Blue MAGA.
And I thought uncritically absorbing the media narrative was a neolib/apolitical thing, but here we are. Turns out people of all political persuasions are susceptible to falling into poor thinking patterns when they reinforce what they already thought.
 

tippy2k2

Beloved Tyrant
Legacy
Mar 15, 2008
14,806
2,256
118
Depends what you mean by "support". Support him in what? I'm certainly not supporting his approach to Gaza.



Well, as I've said, i don't believe that's what happened. That's party spin, like Biden now trying to take credit.



And I thought uncritically absorbing the media narrative was a neolib/apolitical thing, but here we are. Turns out people of all political persuasions are susceptible to falling into poor thinking patterns when they reinforce what they already thought.
Got it, everyone is lying to make Biden look bad. It can't possibly be that Trump did something, everyone is just against Biden and wants to make him look bad.

FAKE NEWS!!!! WITCH HUNT!!!! OPEN YOUR EYES SHEEPLE!!!!!!! TAKE THE HORSE DEWORMER TO WAKE UP!!!!!!!!!!!!
 

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
12,411
6,504
118
Country
United Kingdom
Got it, everyone is lying to make Biden look bad. It can't possibly be that Trump did something, everyone is just against Biden and wants to make him look bad.

FAKE NEWS!!!! WITCH HUNT!!!! OPEN YOUR EYES SHEEPLE!!!!!!! TAKE THE HORSE DEWORMER TO WAKE UP!!!!!!!!!!!!
Well, the Republican Party machine is lying to make Trump look good. That's all. Its their job, just as the Democratic Party machine frequently lies to make Biden look good. But on this, you're credulously believing the spin from one of 'em rather than applying scepticism to both.
 

tippy2k2

Beloved Tyrant
Legacy
Mar 15, 2008
14,806
2,256
118
Well, the Republican Party machine is lying to make Trump look good. That's all. Its their job, just as the Democratic Party machine frequently lies to make Biden look good. But on this, you're credulously believing the spin from one of 'em rather than applying scepticism to both.
Yes yes, it's all FAKE NEWS. All the reports coming from Israel and Bibi are also lying. It's all spin to make The Republicans look good and Democrats look bad. FAKE NEWS!
 

Gordon_4

The Big Engine
Legacy
Apr 3, 2020
6,554
5,814
118
Australia
Yes yes, it's all FAKE NEWS. All the reports coming from Israel and Bibi are also lying. It's all spin to make The Republicans look good and Democrats look bad. FAKE NEWS!
Point of order, has Trump's inauguration actually taken place yet? Because I'm not sure how he's turning any screws other than doing the old Hollywood tactic of negotiating in the press by broadcasting far and wide what he intends to do when in office. And the Israeli government, like any sensible government, will take that seriously and act accordingly.

Of course if the inauguration has been and gone and I missed it, that question is irrelevant.
 

tippy2k2

Beloved Tyrant
Legacy
Mar 15, 2008
14,806
2,256
118
Point of order, has Trump's inauguration actually taken place yet? Because I'm not sure how he's turning any screws other than doing the old Hollywood tactic of negotiating in the press by broadcasting far and wide what he intends to do when in office. And the Israeli government, like any sensible government, will take that seriously and act accordingly.

Of course if the inauguration has been and gone and I missed it, that question is irrelevant.
Because as the President Elect, he has absolutely zero power and is unable to negotiate at all and no world leaders will take anything he says seriously because he's just a private citizen and isn't about to become one of the most powerful people in the country...

I'm sorry it turns out that your boy Biden is a fucking monster but you all don't have to keep defending him and his bloodlust for Palestinian lives...

If these events haven't convinced you that Biden and The Democrats are absolute Evil with a Capital E, then I'm not sure what they could possibly do to convince you (and because so many of you get confused if I don't say this as well every time, Republicans are also absolute Evil with a Capital E. This is just a case showing Biden and Democrats are the Evil this time).
 

Gordon_4

The Big Engine
Legacy
Apr 3, 2020
6,554
5,814
118
Australia
Because as the President Elect, he has absolutely zero power and is unable to negotiate at all and no world leaders will take anything he says seriously because he's just a private citizen and isn't about to become one of the most powerful people in the country...
I just wanted to clarify who was still ostensibly in charge and in active negotiations with the Israelis. I'm aware the President-Elect is not without power but they can't ratify anything until they take the oath. So yeah, he negotiated in the press. Worked too.

Christ, if Biden was the one to say take horse dewormer instead of the Covid vaccine rather than Trump, you'd all be first in line at the pet store to get your hands on it.
No because the Department of Health wasn't giving that kind of inane and stupid advice.

I'm sorry it turns out that your boy Biden is a fucking monster but you don't have to keep defending him and his bloodlust for Palestinian lives...
My guy's name is Anthony Albanese, might want to double check that location tag my man.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mister Mumbler

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
12,411
6,504
118
Country
United Kingdom
Yes yes, it's all FAKE NEWS. All the reports coming from Israel and Bibi are also lying. It's all spin to make The Republicans look good and Democrats look bad. FAKE NEWS!
What have we actually heard from Israel and Netanyahu on this? All I've seen so far is the comment from that Likud media stand-in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Satinavian

Seanchaidh

Elite Member
Legacy
Mar 21, 2009
5,886
3,572
118
Country
United States of America
Fail to see the relevance of this to the central point i made. As if a smaller occupying power somehow only has interest in military capacity for immediate needs, even if the opportunity exists to hoard it and get it cheaply.
Its capacity to generate wealth in general and military resources in particular is a great deal less than the so far most powerful empire in world history.
 

tstorm823

Elite Member
Legacy
Aug 4, 2011
7,340
970
118
Country
USA
At a simple level, Canada and Mexico are a lot less right-wing than the USA. Take over Canada, realistically that's about 10 new states.
If you make each province a state, but all of Canada has barely more people than California, you could make bigger pieces if you really wanted to.
 

Satinavian

Elite Member
Legacy
Apr 30, 2016
1,983
823
118
The US has little problems with cohesion, it's the best assimilation/civic nationalistic system in the world right now,
Which is why the Philippines form several states of the US right now and Cuba is another one, right ? And no one talks about Puerto Ricans as if they were another nationality, correct ?
 
Last edited:

Silvanus

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 15, 2013
12,411
6,504
118
Country
United Kingdom
Its capacity to generate wealth in general and military resources in particular is a great deal less than the so far most powerful empire in world history.
OK. Yet still huge.

So to be clear, are you genuinely arguing that a country like Israel would have no interest in maintaining or increasing military capability beyond its immediate requirements? And that, given an opportunity to carry out its operations with less cost to itself, it wouldn't take it if not absolutely required?
 

Schadrach

Elite Member
Legacy
Mar 20, 2010
2,226
435
88
Country
US
Point of order, has Trump's inauguration actually taken place yet? Because I'm not sure how he's turning any screws other than doing the old Hollywood tactic of negotiating in the press by broadcasting far and wide what he intends to do when in office. And the Israeli government, like any sensible government, will take that seriously and act accordingly.

Of course if the inauguration has been and gone and I missed it, that question is irrelevant.
Jan 20th. The term of a POTUS ends at noon on January 20th of the appropriate year, at which point their successor takes over. Barring some emergency scenario where the order of succession kicks in and someone becomes POTUS outside the normal schedule because something happened to the current one.
 

Thaluikhain

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 16, 2010
19,248
3,964
118
Mexico is a longer-term project, and Canada only has 30ish million people. We could settle new people into Canada. Also, many Mexican-Americans/Americans are even more patriotic than I am.
That's people from Mexico who've chosen to go to the US, not people in Mexico when the US annexes it.


Then I'll ask this as clearly as possible without any other talking points or messages to fuzzy it up

Why the FUCK could Biden not do this?
Well, it remains to be seen if this ceasefire sticks, and how important Trump was. But Biden could have tried doing something. Or, actually, if he'd done nothing, if he'd not increased the amount of weapons and money the US were giving to Israel while the latter was committing genocide, that'd be an improvement.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crimson5pheonix