I definitely enjoyed what I played of Underrail, though I never beat it. But it's really the sorta game I need breaks from, but incredibly unfriendly towards taking breaks from. Since it lacks basic things like a map(though now that I look it up, it appears they have added one?) - it's all too easy to forget what you were doing and lose track of things.I'm playing Underrail.
It's... a bad game. That should be a good one, and at least some people will love.
It's very recognisable in a Fallout-y (1&2) sort of way. It's got a stupidly high learning curve, which is annoying: you have all these apparent options for character development, but in fact the mechanics force min-maxing, so really you have a choice of min-max builds. This means you can start a game, and 20h in realise it's fatally flawed and have to start from scratch. Or you spend hours checking forums before you even start, because then you'll hit the difficulty wall, but at least you won't have wasted them with a useless build that needs to be scrapped.
Having got past the crunch and realised min-maxing isn't wankery but necessity, I'm now stuck in the huge, sprawling play area that requires vast amounts of dull trudging around to fulfill missions that are never quite as exciting as you'd like them to be. And there is so much trudging. I mean, there's loads of hours of gameplay - it's just a lot of it isn't fun.
That's kinda basically what happened to me, I took a break from it and just could not get back into it. I remember the game not giving you a 'home' so I ended up stashing my shit in random trashcans across the world. And I basically forgot where I put what. At least in FO2 you had companions and your car. Thankfully I was playing a Psy character so I didn't have to deal with weapons and ammunition. Though I remember having to weight manage and backtrack a lot to discombobulate various monster parts into recovery items.
I think the game could've benefited with a bit more user friendliness and a few modern niceties. But bringing this up to most fans will just have to rage on you for being a casual.