I agree with most of your sentiments, but even being a stressed teenager, the ability to sit down and continue playing after killing your father is just, sociopathic. Again though, we probably don't have full insight to the kid's life so all we're doing is just speculation. For all we know he could be a very trouble teenager or just a delusional sociopath. Either way, help is in order, but I do feel some prison time would be necessary.FungTheDestroy said:I can see your reasoning. My view is always to ask "is this the only way? Can it be done differently?".The stance I'm trying to take is that the justice court system is wrong in the way it tries to do things.The way I'm stating it, is the court is based on punishing actions, than finding a solution to the problem that caused that action. Putting him in jail is a punishment to his actions, but it also adds to the problem of isolation that he suffered from the beginning.brucelee13245 said:Being a law student I'm kinda looking at it through the eyes of the court. I do see what you mean about the lack of human interaction. But, I do believe that at least some jail time should be necessary in this case considering the crime was so horrendous. On top of that there definitely needs to be some sort of reformation (for lack of a better term)of the child.FungTheDestroy said:That's the exact thing I said, though. He wasn't right minded. He'd isolated himself from society for a full week, disconnected from human emotion, proofed enough by the bloody murder of his Father. But when I hear him being accused of being broken in the mind, it sounds like you're all saying that he had a brain malfunction that naturally came into effect, that society and video games (or any other isolated activity!) had nothing to do with him losing the ability to love and forgive. Maybe it was his interaction with video games over interaction with humans that lead him to be this way?brucelee13245 said:This may be true, but he DID murder his father. Though it will most likely ruin the rest of his life, he SHOULD be prosecuted for murder. And although i agree with you about stressful teenage years, does this justify a right minded fourteen year old's brutal killing of his father? And who knows, maybe deep down he wasn't right minded and there was really something wrong up there.FungTheDestroy said:Major Edit: Just hit me he's 14. People, a person doesn't have to be a complete psycho to go out and kill. He's a teenager, going through the most stressful, confusing, and oppressive years of his life. Every think about that? That the pain of life is so much that he has isolated himself in the world of video games, and any attempt to rip him from comfort leads to blind bloody revenge? I have never met a truly happy teenager in Canada; I bet it's just as bad in Russia
Prosecution and social oppression are the reasons teenagers get like this. Charging them like a serial killer will do no one no good. Especially since the other victim is the mother, who would want the last thing to be her son in jail for a long time. "Punishment", in my opinion, should be to replace his father in some way. Get a job, take responsibility for some of the house work.Putting him in jail would just make the woman suffer more.
One issue I see in the future (not knowing how the Russian Judicial system operated) is this tragedy will be on some sort of record and employers will have a hard time employing him. Lots of things are considered.
I agree, reformation is necessary. I have no idea what the Russian system is like, so I don't know what kind of treatment he'll get in jail.
Same to the other point, his future will be hard now. A permanent stain that will go beyond any of his jail years.
That's how it should be. That "kid" isAustin MacKenzie said:under Russian law he is old enough to be charged with murder.
Or it could feature on Fox News and everyone would laugh at the ridiculous claims those people make.Jaded Scribe said:This is crazy. Unfortunately, I'm sure if CNN or other parental groups get a hold of it, it will become another story of how "violent video games are ruining our kids" rather than seeing it for what it is: a kid with severe emotional and rage issues finally acts out, and in the worst way.
The psychologically unstable are attracted to all sorts of things. Videogames are no exception.GamingAwesome1 said:Why the hell does our hobby attract the psychologically unstable people?