CoCage said:
Casual Shinji said:
The Last of Us 2
The vibe I'm getting thus far is 'Gay girlfriend gets killed, prompting Ellie to go on revenge rampage', which.. please don't Naughty Dog. Please just don't.
As much as I don't care for LoUs, I doubt ND would screw it up that much. If they do, ND will be another developer suffering from dark and "edgy" syndrome.
Yeah, but they also made
Uncharted 3. They
can royally screw up a narrative.
Catfood220 said:
I have no hope that The Last of Us 2 will be any good. The first game was supposed to be about love and was an unrelenting misery fest. The second one is based on hate apparently which immediately makes it sound like a joy to play. I will be giving it a massive miss.
The first game wasn't supposed to be about love. The quote was "If the first the game was about love, then the second game is about hate." Indicating that since the first game was about the love between Joel and Ellie, the second game is or can be about the hate between them, or more specifically, about Ellie finding out what Joel did. At least, let's hope so.
Bilious Green said:
I'm getting a similar feeling, but add, "Joel reluctantly goes along with her, and gets killed along the way, making Ellie realize that the price of vengeance is too high" or something equally predictable. I hope I'm wrong and Neil Druckmann has some sort of surprise in store, but I'm not counting my chickens. I've no doubt the game will be a technical masterpiece, just not sure how the narrative will end up.
I think that would be
too predictable. I don't think Joel is going to die, since that would be a complete waste of that whole lie that's between him and Ellie. There's even a small hint of that in the last trailer. That needs to be followed up on, and I doubt ND would be so incompetent to just kill Joel off without that coming to a conclusion, whether positive or negative.
It's just with what I've seen I'm anxious the game is making mistakes the first one didn't. Joel was never angsty or revenge driven. Not that that means the story will automatically suck if so, I mean,
Berserk managed to make it shine, but it's rare outside of that.
It would also feel like one step forward, two steps back, where we have a gay love interest for the main protagonist, but she gets killed off to fuell the plot. Like, just give a protagonist a nice proper romantic relationship in a videogame.
Now even if my worries do indeed turn out to be true, Naughty Dog can still succeed in making it work, because overall their games are always pretty predictable. You knew Sarah was going to die at the start of
TLoU, and you knew Joel and Ellie would go from disliking eachother to becoming inseperable. And the game made it work expertly despite you knowing it would happen. There's also something in that last trailer that I think points toward an interesting way the narrative might unfold. We go from the barn party to guerilla murder, and then back to the barn party. Maybe this is just to give the trailer some flavour, but I had heard rumors about the game taking place over two points in time. So that could mean that the game will switch back and forth, and that even if this Dina character gets killed we might not know how or why till the end of the game.
I mean, I'm still very much looking forward to it, it's just that I love the first game and I thought the ending was perfect, so any follow-up is going to have me a bit on edge.