nilcypher said:
Being from across the aforementioned pond, I can say yes, we do like Avatar over here, although not me personally, as I'm nearly 30. Pretty much all the anime we get is Americanised, as the dubs are usually done by American voice actors, and no, I don't think that we'd prefer a white actor, certainly not for the reason you suggest anyway.
The 'potentially subpar Asian actor' you're referring to is Dev Patel, star of Slumdog Millionaire. You may have heard of it, it won some awards.
Finally, in the grand scheme of things, movies based on anime really pales in comparison to discrimination in the media.
Belated response, but whatever.
Geez. I was just asking some fucking questions, and having not watched many movies
anyway, no, I have not heard of Dev Patel. The last thing I heard about with casting (aside from the horribly bad Legend of Chun Li), was the Chinese getting pissed that Ken Watanbe was going to play a character in a movie about ancient China. Understandable. What I don't think is understandable is people bitching about race in a movie about four regions. In case you haven't heard of them, they are:
1. Air Nomads
2. Water Tribe
3. Earth Kingdom
4. Fire Nation
Oh, snap. I don't see anything involving places like ASIA or EUROPE in there. Also, having
not lived in Japan, ever, I was asking questions about whether people in Japan actually
care about Avatar. Not stating as some sort of cold hard fact that they don't.
And I'd like to point out that I said
potentially because someone could always be
potentially bad. You couldn't, say, have some random British person who's never acted before play Harry Potter in the movies and have him automatically better than any American actor ever born. Let's see some other things that I pointed out but you oh so conveniently ignored. "Assuming," "going on a limb," nearly the entire first paragraph having question marks, indicating that there may very well be a chance that
I didn't fucking know.
And yes. I am aware that racism in the media is a problem. Just like in everything else, with a nice wonderful helping of double standard that lets people hate on me for being a white American male and not have any trouble. But what's most certainly a step in the wrong direction is bitching about the casting in a movie with source material that doesn't focus on race, on the basis of race no less, when said movie is going to be shit regardless.
I didn't see anything else about this. I saw the single news post. I had questions. I asked them. I threw a comment in stating my opinion that the item in question probably doesn't matter because it'll be an underwhelming piece of shit that people will forget. Don't bite my fucking head off for that.