ForgottenPr0digy said:
Treblaine said:
I'm sorry but MGS2 does make sense. The Patriots choose Raiden to test of GW they made the Big Shell aka "memories of shadow Moses"
Back in MGS1 Snake asked a lot question when Liquid was explaining the Human Genome project. Snake was just as clueless as Snake was on his mission as well
"The Patriots choose Raiden to test of GW they made the Big Shell aka 'memories of shadow Moses' "
that does Not make ANY sense. GW makes no sense, why do they need some (supposed) ex-child soldier to "test GW"
Who makes an ENTIRE FACILITY just to recreate the "memories" of a character for a completely different character who has no memories of said thing? They build Big Shell on top in a retarded attempt to conceal the assembly of Arsenal Gear (oh god the stupidity of locating a building project so close to a major population centre and amongst such a high profile clean-up... so dumb)
MGS2 is full of bullshit that makes no sense only seeks to hide it amongst the confusion of endless exposition:
Like Snake letting Ninja/Olga electrocute and capture Raiden only to release him later, don't tell me that was to get him onto Arsenal gear, Snake got on just fine: Lazy Writing. Couldn't be bothered to code for an infiltration scene onto arsenal. And how did Olga and Snake come to work together?!? Last time they were trying to kill each other.
GW is the bullshit idea that one supercomputer can control all information to control a country, that is such an unmitigated bullshit anti-climax that I want to break my PS2 when I heard it. it's some bullshit that an artist like David Hockney would come up with and absolutely NO ONE takes remotely seriously nor even bothers to entertain the thought.
Another thing: if the Colonel Campbell is a virtual reality construct by GW over codec... who did Raiden know in real life? Who PHYSICALLY sent him on this mission? If he has not really been in Foxhound, where has he been?! MGS1 explained all this with the "Briefing" option as Solid Snake has a recorded conversation with the Colonel to ask all the questions he likes and in the process drop in how he ended up in a nuclear submarine speeding towards an Alaskan archipelago and what he was going before.
MGS1 stayed just on the right side of "dumb but serviceable" with the human genome project as it was just Liquid's insane ranting about "recessive genes" at least it served to explain their common lineage and was justification for Liquid's antagonism to Snake.
Mut MGS2 just goes too far, they say that even though the human-genome project only found 30-40 thousand genes the script retardation says "no actually there are 100 thousand genes". WHY?
-Because an early ESTIMATE a wild guess by scientists thought there would be 100-thousand (truth is many genes have double functions hence the discrepancy between predicted and actual)
-the remaining 60-thousand genes were "suppressed" an the scientific papers "subtly altered" to the point that the thousands of scientists around the world all accept that 60% OF THEIR FUCKING DATA IS JUST GONE!!!! Are you fucking kidding me?!?!
-The justification: "Well, are YOU a geneticists? have you counted the genes yourself" HO-LEE-FUCK! That is the most retarded thing to say in the world, that's like saying "9/11 it was all a hoax, oh yeah how can you contradict me
WHERE YOU THERE?"
-Oh and they imply that those 60-thousand genes contained genes "The Patriots didn't want the world to know about" which is just shamelessly stupid and shows an incredible amount of ignorance on how genes actually make a phenotype. Genes just make proteins, a couple proteins or another won't make you a super soldier nor super-anything, it's the combination of ALL the genes in the right balance.
The gene/meme thing was a lame subplot but then it became THE plot. Mainly because Kojima has no clue about the significance of memes and the idea he does have is boring as some 13 year old's philosophy thesis that is more interested in word plays than actual conundrums.
MGS1's plot was ALWAYS on course and clear, it was all about nuclear blackmail to build a genome army. That was the plot and the theme, stop the terrorists, save the world, hopefully get the girl.
Rule number 1: the plot is ONLY THERE for the characters, to give them motivation and bring out aspects of them-self. If the characters are lame or poorly fleshed out, the plot is pointless for the audience.
The worst part is The Patriots are a completely unseen and completely unbelievable foe, all you have is a bunch of very crazy characters rabbit on about what they may or may not have done, they seem more like a figment of the conspiracist imagination. And I'm sorry but it is 100% BULLSHIT that democracy is a massive facade set up by The Patriots in America. Or at least if you say that you have to offer some compelling proof than a totally unbelievable president simply saying so, that is NOT ENOUGH. Just because it is stated in banal exposition doesn't make it remotely believable.
That's the problem with MGS2's plot... endless... endless... dry exposition. The plot is LITERALLY told to you by the characters, often even more lazily if two people are in the same room they'll switch to codec - using the bullshit excuse that "oooh, someone could be listening". Bullshit.
And don't tell me MGS2 was carefully constructed as the final justification for Raiden fighting Solidus is:
"Yeah, you better fight him coz we got your real girlfriend and we'll kill her. Also we got the baby of some woman that you barely know, we'll kill the baby too."
Oh yeah, it all comes down to some bullshit like THAT!?!? Dastardly shit like that?
The final confrontation is beyond ridiculous, everyone is revealed to be a Patriot double or triple agent. The problem is this is devoid of reason as no one had any idea what they were supposed to be doing in the first place let alone what they actually were doing.
It is a fucking mess of bullshit, the S3 program has two different contradicting explanations and absolutely no proof it really exists at all and again, to spite all this mess... where is the drama? I have no idea what they are fighting for and it is just a mess
MGS1 had a neat plot to centre around the homicidal sibling rivalry, with the practical plot being nuclear blackmail with a superweapon.
but Raiden's supposed paternal link to Solidus is paper thin. He was adopted at quite an old age (not a baby) and was used as a child soldier (sound more like just plain old kidnapping to me) which he doesn't remember anyway. So, no blood link + no memorial link = no fucking link between those characters! If there was, there is no way an audience can feel it, it's just mentioned in banal exposition and delivered with such lack of emotion or context.
The "I am you Father... kinda" is just SOOOO blatantly tacked on at the last minute, it was not built up to at all. I mean when Solidus met Raiden before the torture scene (rip-off from MGS1) there was NO RECOGNITION, no acknowledgement nor even hint of any connection from either of them. Just villain A vs "hero" B.
The reason for the final fight with Solidus is pointless and makes no sense "Huahh lets dual to the death, for no reason", The Patriot's exposition/explanation is contradictory and makes even less sense. It's not clear what happened, nothing makes sense, a gigantic ship just crashed through New York to likely kill millions and people are just milling about as if going to work like normal, ignoring the two commandos strapped with guns and swords. And how DID Snake get there if he dived off the side of the ship? Did he swim that far just to high-five Raiden and tell him some bullshit about doing what he wants with his life?
Actually, when Raiden had the ridiculously easy fight with TWENTY FIVE metal gear Rays (I thought each one was supposed to beat the original Rex?) it happens in some strange endless dream-scape, it looks like virtual reality. Then a platform rises up and they're on top of the ship... WHAT THE FUCK!?!?
The game was boring after the tanker and it became trite and surreal at the ending on Arsenal Gear. The retardation and stupidity sets up such an incredible mess the fact that MGS4 had to somehow explain and simultaneously ignore huge parts of MGS2 doomed it to be a mediocre story at best.
So in conclusion:
Worst. game. Ever.