Best "Non Final Fantasy" JRPG Ever?

[Saltyk]

Plenty of candidates, but I always felt Breath of Fire 3 to be underrated because it came out during the FFVII era when everyone was trying to make their own 3D JRPG. Rei and Teepo forever.

I love me some Breath of Fire III to this day, the whole series really.

I thought I was the only one. I literally just played Breath of Fire 3 (again) like a month ago. Easily one of my favorite RPGs. And I played it around the same time as FF7. I liked it in a different way, I guess.

There are a whole ton of PSOne era JRGs that are just awesome. The PSOne RPGs were my first time ever playing RPGs and I love a ton of them.

How has no one said Legend of Legaia!? A deep combat system and the most unique magic system I can think of in just about any game.

 

[Sakurazaki1023]

Lost Odyssey, fantastic game in my opinion. Had some excellent characters and felt very epic.

It certainly made me empathise with the characters which is a job well done in my book.

Lost Odyssey is just the best jrpg ever.

I dont like how it says "best NON Final Fantasy game" because Lost Odyssey is far far superior to Final Fantasy.

Glad to know people think so highly of it. I bought it on a whim last time I was at Gamespot but haven't started it since I'm in the middle of Resonance Of Fate and enjoying it way too much to stop now. As soon as I beat Resonance, it's the first thing in my 360.

 

[JWW]

All I've played is Pokemon Yellow, so I guess that is where my vote goes.

 

[drisky]

Tales of Symphonia is one of my favorite games of all time. Another big one for me was the Golden Sun games and World Ends with you. There way better than any Final Fantasy, in fact I've never considered any of the numbered Final Fantasys all that great, there pretty over rated.

 

[Lunar Templar]

o.0 ....
long answer so lets get to it
Chrono Trigger
Shadow Hearts
SMT: Nocturne
SMT: Digital Devil Saga
Legend of the Dragoon
Breath of Fire
Valkyrie Profile: Lenneth
Seiken Densetsu (that's The Secret of Mana)
Lufia
Lunar
Super Mario RPG
Paper Mario
Parasite Eve

yeah, lotta old school games, but hey, most those are STILL BETTER then games today
and no, can't just pick one

 

[WanderingFool]

Lost Odyssey, fantastic game in my opinion. Had some excellent characters and felt very epic.

It certainly made me empathise with the characters which is a job well done in my book.

Lost Odyssey is just the best jrpg ever.

I dont like how it says "best NON Final Fantasy game" because Lost Odyssey is far far superior to Final Fantasy.

I think it was more, "Best JRPG, no Final Fantasy answers allowed." Could be wrong...

 

[Karthesios]

I have to second the Star Ocean games. Story notwithstanding (I started with 2, and it's far from my favorite JRPG story but I still loved the hell out of the game), the games' combat systems are some of the most addicting things I've ever played. SO3 stands as the only game where I've ever put more than 100 hours into one save file.

 

[Ace of Spades]

Skies of Arcadia: Legends, hands down.

 

[Nayr]

Golden sun, or any tales game basically ever. Tales games basically get me through the day haha. but tales of symphonia and tales of versperia were my favorites by far. They were the only games i have beaten multiple times and enjoyed them each time.

 

[llamastorm.games]

Lost Odyssey, fantastic game in my opinion. Had some excellent characters and felt very epic.

It certainly made me empathise with the characters which is a job well done in my book.

Lost Odyssey is just the best jrpg ever.

I dont like how it says "best NON Final Fantasy game" because Lost Odyssey is far far superior to Final Fantasy.

I think it was more, "Best JRPG, no Final Fantasy answers allowed." Could be wrong...

Yeah, probably. Final Fantasy would be far to easy an answer for most people.

 

[llamastorm.games]

Lost Odyssey, fantastic game in my opinion. Had some excellent characters and felt very epic.

It certainly made me empathise with the characters which is a job well done in my book.

Lost Odyssey is just the best jrpg ever.

I dont like how it says "best NON Final Fantasy game" because Lost Odyssey is far far superior to Final Fantasy.

Glad to know people think so highly of it. I bought it on a whim last time I was at Gamespot but haven't started it since I'm in the middle of Resonance Of Fate and enjoying it way too much to stop now. As soon as I beat Resonance, it's the first thing in my 360.

Get the tissues ready for disk 2.

 

[Sacman]

Nier totally underrated...

 

[dillirgaf]

Rogue Galaxy for PS2 was a lot of fun

 

[The Golden Sun]

Golden Sun hands down.

 

[Sakurazaki1023]

Lost Odyssey, fantastic game in my opinion. Had some excellent characters and felt very epic.

It certainly made me empathise with the characters which is a job well done in my book.

Lost Odyssey is just the best jrpg ever.

I dont like how it says "best NON Final Fantasy game" because Lost Odyssey is far far superior to Final Fantasy.

Glad to know people think so highly of it. I bought it on a whim last time I was at Gamespot but haven't started it since I'm in the middle of Resonance Of Fate and enjoying it way too much to stop now. As soon as I beat Resonance, it's the first thing in my 360.

Get the tissues ready for disk 2.

Glad to know.

If a game can get you so emotionally involved with it's characters that you are forced to reach for the tissues at major plot points, I'd say that's the sign of a great game.

 

[Doctor Panda]

Epic Battle Fantasy 3 (a flash send up of final fantasy, but awesome)

 

[deckai]

Well, I vote for Terranigma! Close behind, Secret of Mana, Chrono Trigger and Tales of Symphonia ... but to be honest, every game mentioned until now is incredible good and worth to be played.

 

[SovietSecrets]

Chrono Trigger. Pretty sure its been said somewhere already.

 

[HijiriOni]

Lufia 2, Lufia 1, Lunar: Silver Star Story.

 

[llamastorm.games]

Lost Odyssey, fantastic game in my opinion. Had some excellent characters and felt very epic.

It certainly made me empathise with the characters which is a job well done in my book.

Lost Odyssey is just the best jrpg ever.

I dont like how it says "best NON Final Fantasy game" because Lost Odyssey is far far superior to Final Fantasy.

Glad to know people think so highly of it. I bought it on a whim last time I was at Gamespot but haven't started it since I'm in the middle of Resonance Of Fate and enjoying it way too much to stop now. As soon as I beat Resonance, it's the first thing in my 360.

Get the tissues ready for disk 2.

Glad to know.

If a game can get you so emotionally involved with it's characters that you are forced to reach for the tissues at major plot points, I'd say that's the sign of a great game.

I have never in my life even been close to misty eyed whilst playing a game but in one scene on disk 2 is like an emotional mallet to the face.