undeadsuitor said:
Silentpony said:
Wow.
Or...they could just tell a separate characters story in another time period that doesn't touch Shepard's? They have already been talking about the possibility of different playable races ala Dragon Age Origins and Inquisition.
Are you seriously saying that the 10 or so characters from the main trilogy are the only characters in the entire universe?
They can't really do another time period at this point, can they? If you do prequel, well no matter what happens, it all works out in the end because the ME games still happen. There can be no risk of Galactic extinction because the Reaper arc hasn't occurred yet. You can't have it set in the past because we already know how it ends. With the first ME game. And you have to do a Galactic extinction plot to keep up the epic feel. That was the problem with DA2. We went from the stalwart hero of the land to some street thug type guy(or gal) who slowly does shit that doesn't really matter. You can't jump down in scale for your plot - it makes it seem weak and meaningless.
And you can't do a sequel because of the mess that was ME3's ending. Too many variables. Players would insist on being able to import if not their Shepard, then at least the story they built. Did the Quarians die, is Wrex dead, synthesis vs destruction etc...Some players had the Reapers win - do they not get to import their story and get no say in whats going on? The problems facing a destroyed Reaper galaxy are not going to be the same as those of a dead Quarian, no Krogan cure synthesis one. They would have to do something so completely removed from the Galactic stage and race relations - the two staples of ME mind you - that they might as well make up an entire new game and IP. Just start over instead of riding the ME wave while claiming to be something new and different.
Bioware made such an absolute mess of ME3 that the franchise is essentially untouchable. Its like the Schumacher Batman and Robin. No one can touch the entire franchise for years. ME3 is still too fresh in our minds. If we play a new one, we'll be too tempted to look for any possible clue to if Shepard or the crew lived we'll miss the game's plot. Does the grizzled cop and intrepid reporter stop the Krogan smugglers? Who cares! I want to know if Tali and Shepard find each other and live happily on Rannoch.
Anything less than Mass Effect 4: Just kidding Shepard is back will leave the fans with such a case of blue balls they'll wonder why Bioware doesn't just make an entirely new IP again.